Guest, I quoted the many articles and essays he has written about WW1 that are available on line. His book has little relevance to this debate because it is mostly about other armies and theatres of war, and only covers the first four months of the war anyway.

Greg, all histories of WW1 written in recent decades.
I remind you that none of you, in three years of debate, have found one that supports Jim's debunked and discredited historical myths.

Unless and until you do, there is no point in continuing.