Dave,
There are plenty of current historians who do not agree with the Keith/Teribus/HiLo assessment.

We all know there used to be some historians who used to believe those now debunked myths.
That is why I always refer to everything written in the last twenty years. Neither of your two have written anything on WW1 in that time.
Older than that hardly counts as "current" Dave!

No historian still believes those old discredited myths you cling to.
Unless and until you find one, please stop wasting our time.