Modette may have a doctorate.
She attacks me for saying the historians all agree my points even though it is a fact, and she attacked me for saying they did not all agree on blame for the famine, which is also a fact.

I put this to you again Dr. modette,

My views come from reading WW1 histories.
Nothing written in the last twenty years contradict them.
Nothing written in the last twenty years supports the views expressed by Jim.

Do you challenge any of those facts modette?
If you do, please give details.
I provide quotes from numerous historians working on that period.
What can you provide?