You have done your usual trick of taking a small slice of the massive amount of evidence and what she has written to back your support ofg terrorism - you have given an unlinked quote
You have just called Nurse Seigal a liar - I ask again - who else has ever made such a claim? - anywhere Israelis - the Israeli lobby - who?
A failure to respond to this question will confirm what we already know - that you make things up on behalf of terrorism
Yopu are now running away from your claim that Redmond left it open - hao can (using your own words) "The Redmond Enquiry found Israel guilty either "directly or indirectly" of the Sabra/Shatila massacre" possibly be described as "leaving it open"?
He said they were guilty of one or the other - it transpired they were possibly guilty of both - we will probably never know which as the Yanks vetoed them being tried - we can make up our own minds - Human Rights groups and honest human beings, including Israelis all over the planet believe them to be guilty - given their track record - that'll do for me.
One more time - Ellen Seigal is a liar - sez who?
Jim Carroll
By the way, you claim Israel has never committed massacres - Wiki lists four definite ones on Palestinian territory - the article appeals for more information.
The number of assassinations carried out by Israeli security forces makes interesting reading too.