"Well done, but you could just be saying that couldn't you - "
He could, just as you could be (and do) saying everything you say, especially as you don't ever supply links.
Keith boasts he has not read books on this subject and only quotes things he has found on the internet after the subject has come up He ones spectacularly foot-in-mouthed by claiming he had read one of the most difficult books on Stalinism and yet was totally unable to answer a basic question to back up his claim - he didn't attempt to answer, he just ignored requests to do so..... so when it comes to claims, neither of you are shining lights in the veracity stakes.
Jim Carroll