Joe, I know you are trying to pour oil and troubled waters but although we all often make mistakes I draw a line when someone deliberately lies and then continues to do so.

When one contributor claims from the rooftops that there are 3 criticisms of a book when in reality is in fact one criticism of a book, which that contributor then claims to be criticisms of that author works, it has to be pointed out.

If once pointed out that contributor had said Ooops my mistake, it would not have gone any further. However both you and I know said contributor will NEVER acknowledge they are in the wrong.

In one post that contributor actually libelled the author of the book in question. I would like to think the said author would take an action against the contributor and I've saved the offending posts just in case he does.

This one contributor is renowned for trying to "mislead" others. Some of us call that lying.