Joe Offer - 20 May 16 - 04:06 AM

1: I have never ever stated that I thought or in any way believed that Ireland was not entitled to independence.

2: But Jim Carroll clearly stated in one of his posts that that is what I had said.

3: I have been requesting Jim Carroll to direct me to the post in which I said that I believed that Ireland was not entitled to independence. He has steadfastly refused to do this.

(As stated by Keith A - I too am a great believer in supporting the right to self-determination for ALL).

4: The point I am trying make should be fairly obvious I did not and have never ever stated that I thought that Ireland was not entitled to independence and I want a clear statement from Carroll that acknowledges that fact.

Whenever I have been shown to be in error, I have apologised and admitted my error - I have done so to you and to Raggytash on this very thread.

but it seems crystal-clear that the point you were making over and over again, was that Ireland was not entitled to independence.

When Joe? please give me an example, one should be pretty easy to come up with if what you say is true.