"Jim, if I am repeating things that are untrue, identify one."
Now you really do have to be joking
Every time you have written that Ireland would have become independent if it hadn't been for the uprising, you have repeated a lie.
You have been given masses of evidence that this was not the case, you have not countered that with anything whatever of your own, yet you have continued to repeat it as if you were saying it for the first tome
It is not true, it has been proven to be false with accredited facts, you have totally failed to come up with an accredited fact - not one singe "real historian", yet you continue to repeat it.
That is just one of many of your 'cracked record impressions'.
If thete are no responses from this pair, I will continue with my assesment of the period, moving on to the enforced Treaty and probably finishing with the effect that that Treaty had on the Catholic minority of the six counties - that shoul;d sort out the rest of the week.
Jim Carroll