The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #160036   Message #3793868
Posted By: Lighter
04-Jun-16 - 08:40 PM
Thread Name: Origins: How do I determine if a song is trad?
Subject: RE: Origins: How do I determine if a song is trad?
Sometimes it depends on the text and tune.

"Jesse James," for example, is probably trad, but there may be more than one song with that title. Years ago I learned a version that had the unusual chorus, "Oh, I don't know where my poor old Jesse's gone," etc., etc. Turns out it was revised and copyrighted.

"Elkhorn Ridge" has a trad sound, but I believe it's been considerably adapted.

"Blackeyed Susie" is certainly trad - unless somebody's created a red-hot bluegrass arrangement of it. In that case....

And so on,