The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #160727   Message #3813747
Posted By: Keith A of Hertford
10-Oct-16 - 03:32 PM
Thread Name: BS: What does 'anti-semitism' mean?
Subject: RE: BS: What does 'anti-semitism' mean?
Kevin and Jim,
But Ayalet Shaked is in fact Israeli Minister of Justice, Keith, and there seems to be convincing evidence that she did make that post which does genocide

No there is not.
Ms Shaked protested that the quote had been mistranslated into English from Hebrew and insisted she was not calling for indiscriminate killing.
Even in the translation, she only refers to those who have given support to actual terrorists, not "all Palestinians."
Once again you swallow all anti-Israel propaganda without question.

Jim,
you refuse even to tell us what the accusations of Antisemitism are and are totally relying on your own interpretation of the opinions of others.

We all are Jim because Labour is keeping it secret, but numerous prominent Labour members and officials, including the entire NEC and even Chakrabarti all state that Labour has a serious problem with antisemitism.
We do know about about Shah's comments.
In yours and Steve's opinion they are not antisemitic, but her antisemitism was recognised by the NEC, the Party leadership, Corbyn and Shah herself, so what is your opinion worth?.

You continue to defend a statement of the Israeli Minister who claims that it is Antisemitic to criticise Israeli policy

No I do not, and I have repeatedly stated that it is not antisemitic.
The minister did not claim it was either.