The point about the prisoners in Guantanamo Bay is that they hadn't had any form of trial. They were technically only 'suspects'. It's wrong in my view to detain anyone at all for years without trial. To then proceed with torturing them is appalling.

Just because one Muslim is a rapist and a murderer doesn't justify imprisoning and torturing any Muslims one happens to 'suspect'.

There isn't any justification for torture. None.