The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #160410   Message #3826299
Posted By: Jim Carroll
13-Dec-16 - 01:31 PM
Thread Name: BS: Labour party discussion
Subject: RE: BS: Labour party discussion
"According to the IHRA definition, "Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis." is anti Semitic"
Avvording to all definitions of antisemitism, it is antisemitic to associate the Jewish People with the actions of Israel
You do it, Bodad does it, Israel does it......
While you people continue to do it you will make shit of any definition and you will continue to expose the jEwish People to attacks
If you think I in any way concerned at being described as an antisemite by someone who has accused the Jewish politicians, as a body, of refusing to identify the antisemitism that is claimed to exist in the Labour Party for the love of that party - think again - that is probably the most antisemitic statement that has ever been made on this forum - AND YOU MADE IT
"Just over 27 percent of those surveyed in September said they agreed with the idea that Israel's treatment of the Palestinians was no different than Nazi persecution of Jews during the Holocaust."
I'm sure that was not intended to confirm what I have just said, but that is exactly what it does do.
Israel has branded the Jewish People as being responsible for their crimes - in doing so, they make shit of any definition.
"Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis."
Leading
Israelis, ex Prime Ministers, Military men, ex heads of security, the liberal Israeli press, Jewish intellectuals, Holocaust survivors and their families..... and many many more Jews, are making just this claim
You once described the phrase "Self hating Jew" as applied to modern Jewish critics of Israel, as having been made up by me - it is now a standard knee-jerk defence of all Israeli crimes
I'm not Jewish, but these are the people I identify with, not the ethnic cleansers of Israel and certainly not people like you and Bobad.