The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #161452   Message #3844872
Posted By: Teribus
14-Mar-17 - 10:42 AM
Thread Name: BS: Uk Labour Party discussion II
Subject: RE: BS: Uk Labour Party discussion II
"I have heard about a lot of shootings and beatings metered out to Muslims."

Really?? Where Gnome? Who was responsible for these shootings and beatings Gnome? Wouldn't be beatings and shootings carried out by other Muslims by any chance would it?

Shaw:
"The figures you've provided in no way confirm the assertion you made."

In what way do they not confirm what bobad stated Shaw? Explain yourself:

"Jews are targeted more than all other religious groups combined in most of the western world today." - bobad

USA:
Anti-Semitic attacks = 52.1% of all reported religious hate crimes
All other combined = 47.9%

Statement made by bobad IS supported wrt the USA

Nothing ambiguous or unclear about it. 52.1% is a greater percentage than 47.9% - True?

"In the context of other types of crime such as robbery, burglary, assault and domestic abuse, you have failed to show that the crimes you're complaining about amount to any kind of crisis." - Shaw

No-one is looking at it "in the context of other types of crime" Shaw - (Nice try at deflecting the argument Shaw but do have a go at "valiantly sticking to the point" in order to stay on track) - and nobody is claiming there is a crisis

Here is the claim once again - "Jews are targeted more than all other religious groups combined in most of the western world today." - bobad

Plain statement of fact - I see no mention of it being of epidemic proportions Shaw, nor do I see any claim there of there being a crisis.