How can it be Home rule in Scotland or elsewhere for that matter, if another country is still ruling us or any other countrty.

Home rule means the people of that country is ruled by the parliment of that country and not a foreigen one.

So explain that.

Scotland is still being ruled by Westminster and so that can't be home rule.

If Edinburgh is being ruled by London.

Home rule for Scotland should be Edinburgh should rule Scotland and not London, ENGLAND.