The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #161452   Message #3866376
Posted By: Keith A of Hertford
16-Jul-17 - 07:51 AM
Thread Name: BS: Uk Labour Party discussion II
Subject: RE: BS: Uk Labour Party discussion II
Steve, I do not lie.
She referred to the relocation of Israel, not the transportation of Jews, as you said she did. You lied.

Not true. She advocated the removal of the population but not the Arabs.
That would complete the cleansing of Jews from the whole middle East.
(Including West Bank, hence its inclusion)
That is what you are defending.

Steve,
This is what Keith said::
"Her statements were anti-Semitic in context, advocating the transportation of the Jews out of Israel."
She made no such statement.

YES SHE DID!!
Guardian, "Labour MP Naz Shah admits to the Guido Fawkes blog she wrote a Facebook post arguing for Israel's population to be "transported" out of the Middle East to America."

Dave, you raised a false comparison.
Morris made an entirely innocuous statement but used an offensive word.
Shah used no offensive words but made anti-Semitic statements.

Rag,
Previously you posted "Steve claimed that to be a lie, and you all backed him"

If you state that you do not back Steve, I will gladly apologise to you.

Jim, we know she did not draw the maps, but what she said on the subject was racist.