I thoroughly agree with KatC that both were jus' fine. And that Nathan & Nynia did extremely All one would hope for. But I do strongly object to the two-room notion. I have to choose which room to be in and clearly I want to be in both. It may be that one might choose based on the actual idea of the thing - do I want to be in an open or closed room? But in reality, one has to mostly choose where the singing's best. And it seems it's best in both places.

I think one can largely Ignore harassers (although I admit I've never had the opportunity to enjoy a harasser) and the admin can always red-dot (turn off) an abuser. The single jerk I've heard sang a few lines with one "naughty" word and ran away. Frankly, I'd like to have heard the rest of the song!

Really, unless the group becomes too large or needs to specialize in types of music, I don't see the advantage in more than one room.

Go open or go closed. Please.