I thought it was a nice thread - with lots of old friends - some of whom are no longer with us. Very passionate. Too long to read it all but I had a nice couple of hours last week running through parts of the thread.

I'm sorry you closed it.

---

I see no reason to argue against the thread closure. The thread had run its course, and was getting circular. It's available for reading indefinitely, but not for posting. If somebody actually comes up with something substantive about MacColl's opinion of Dylan, then start another thread.
-Joe Offer-