The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #9589 Message #4111125
Posted By: Lighter
23-Jun-21 - 12:28 PM
Thread Name: Origins: riddle song (I Gave My Love a Cherry)
Subject: Lyr Add: I HAVE A YOUNG SISTER
The Daily Milwaukee News (Nov. 15, 1855) printed a "modernized" version of this "eccentric ballad" of "about the year 1450":
AN OLD BALLAD
I have a young sister, Far beyond the sea; Many were the presents That she sent me. She sent me a cherry Without any stone She sent me a pigeon, Without any bone; Without any thorns She sent me a briar, She bade me love my lover And that without desire.
How can a cherry Be without a stone? How can a pigeon Be without a bone? How can a briar Be without a thorn? And whoe'er loved without desire Since true love first was born?
When the cherry was a blossom, Then it had no stone; When the dove [sic] was in the egg, Then it had no bone. When first the briar sprouted, Never a thorn it bore; When a maiden has her lover, Oh, then she longs no more.
Pretty neat! It was reprinted in papers in a half-dozen states.
The speaker is clearly female. The twist on her sister's advice in the last line is totally unexpected.