There is actually a parallel thread going on right now which questions the legitamacy of posting these songs because of the stance they take. I would respond that given the nature of the Mudcat, of course we should. One man's terrorist is another man's hero. My views, as most here know, are Irish Republican to the max. I am not some Yank with a fantasy image of Ireland, but rather an Irish American, raised among Irish Emmigrants who had strong Republican feelings. I have studied, and continue to study, the history of the land of my people, and the historical roots of "the troubles". The point of all this is that I have very strong Republican views based on much more than a propagandist's view. And having said all that, it seems to me critically important when dealing with "folk music" that you be inclusive as opposed to exclusive. The music that we are attempting to preserve and pass on MUST reflect all sides of the issues no matter how it may offend my or anyone elses politic, and sometimes their sensibilities. In the fullness of time, "folks" can make their own judgements as to the validity of the causes. But it will be a well reasoned judgement only if it is based on complete data.

Tiocfaidh a/r la/.

Mick