The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #21800   Message #4207962
Posted By: GUEST,Nick Dow
05-Sep-24 - 09:19 AM
Thread Name: Folk song collecting. Good or bad?
Subject: RE: Folk song collecting. Good or bad?
Rossey. With respect- Would you be so kind as to supply your definition of traditional? While you are busy defining, if it is not too offensive for you could you explain why three generations of singers, who still perform for example, 'Down in the fields where the buttercups all grow' fail to qualify under your traditional banner due to the song once being copyrighted, whereas a song like 'A rosebud in June' gleaned directly from the stage in the 18th century is generally included in many collections and repertoires as traditional. While you are at it, if you would not mind, do you agree with the contentious view that states that 'A Folk painting is less of a Folk painting if we know the painter'.
These are serious questions and if you have a love and interest in Folk music, they are worth considering.