Susan=I agree you cannot please everyone, as for cookies, well people use them here so I can't really see a problem. I think if people use Jon's forum, that is good, it proves there was a demand for it, if only a few people use it he is likely to close it, which is fair enough.I know some people are not happy with the non music stuff on Mudcat, and I think Jon has kindly provided an additional area for for this kind of thing, let's hope it is a sucsess.Like I said, it is hard to please everyone, somebody might go to Jon's forum, and say "Why is there nothing about sport?" or whatever.cheers.john