On the topic of Harry Potter not being about any particular religion, I totally agree. I am a witch, and yes, I use magic(k) and other non-mainstream arts and sciences, but these are simply a means of living -- tools. Sometimes we use them to communicate with our subconscience, or other spirits. This "magick" often does play a role in our connection with our religion, but is not neccesarily "fundamental" to pagan belief. Likewise, paganism, "new age", Wicca, Druidism, Satanism, etc... are not fundamental to magic.

Rowling doesn't ever specify the religion of either "muggles" or witches & wizards (as far as I know from what I've read & seen). I think the opposition (which was there before the movie was even announced), is mostly caused by people who fear the acceptance of magic as good or secular in our mostly Abrahamic society. I think this is the root of many people's fear of my faith, as well. The fear is not of our different belief system, but that we presume to study and work with powers and "technologies" that are usually reserved for very holy people, saints, or gods.

Yes, this may all transfer to the Lord of the Rings when it comes out, and indeed, there are people of every faith (witches, too!) who will look for a scandal or proof of Satan's presence in anything, but we can't be quiet for fear of giving them more fodder.

Despite its non-religious story-line, Harry Potter has done for pagan religions what years of our silent acceptance & secret magic-working for peace has not achieved: it has brought into the mainstream (worldwide!) media the notion of magic as a secular, innocent, and useful tool, which, like a knife (thank you, Pete) can be a saviour or a killer. Once more people recognize that, it will be like the harnessing of fire: more people will learn to use this valuable tool, and it will enhance ALL of our lives in ways we cannot yet imagine.

Of course in the book it is still fantasy. But it's a beautiful fantasy, and can open our minds and inspire us to a world most people ignore.

thanks for listening. This is my first time posting at Mudcat, so I hope I haven't broken any code of conduct with my post. --Emily