I have mp3's of all the songs on our cassette. They are all either original or PD. I'd be happy to contribute a song, as well as perhaps a bit of cash to get the CDs made. They don't cost so much anymore, and if everyone put in maybe $10, we could get a couple hundred.Also I'm sure there's a graphic designer in our midst who would be willing to design the jacket.
A CD will hold a LOT of stuff on it - no need to limit to 10-12 songs.
There's been a lot of good ideas bandied about here. If someone wants to start a committee or something to actually get it done, holler at me.