Here's a post from McGrath of Harlow on another thread that provides support for some of the things I have asserted on this thread. I somehow seem to have missed it until now...

=/thread.cfm?threadid=45930&messages=146#681500

Here's the article that McGrath provided a link to on that thread...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4385572,00.html

And here's the article itself, written by Yossi Beilin, who was the Israeli Justice Minister in the government of Ehud Barak. troll, this is especially for you...

A different life is still possible, but it's slipping away

Yossi Beilin
Guardian

Tuesday April 2, 2002

The terrible terrorist events that have struck Israel on the Passover holiday have generated an understandable feeling that "something must be done". Not surprisingly, that has meant waging war on the Palestinian Authority.

Such a war can be justified in many ways, even beyond the natural desire to respond to acts of brutality. The second Palestinian intifada began in September 2000 against the backdrop of a viable political peace process, and it was not restrained by Yasser Arafat at its outbreak. Mass demonstrations were soon replaced by brutal acts of terrorism, some coming from groups closely connected with the Palestinian Authority and Mr Arafat.

But the job of the Israeli government is not merely to explain its actions. It is to ensure the safety of its citizens. A war with the Palestinian Authority would ensure exactly the opposite outcome.

It is easy for many Israelis to cling to the belief that the former prime minister, Ehud Barak, offered Mr Arafat "everything" while Mr Arafat answered him with the intifada. And indeed, Mr Barak did make a considerable peace offer in July 2000 at the Camp David summit. However, it must also be remembered that by December 2000, Mr Arafat had agreed to the Clinton peace plan, as had Mr Barak. Both men did so with reservations, and this act of compromise occurred at the height of the intifada.

But instead of accepting the successful talks that had taken place between Israel and the Palestinians at Taba in Egypt in January 2001 as a way towards a final settlement, Ariel Sharon decided, after being elected prime minister, to terminate the peace process.

He has never concealed his opinion that the Oslo process was wrong. So he brought it to an end with the help of Shimon Peres and the Labour party. First, he delegitimised the Palestinian Authority and Mr Arafat as its leader. He sought the destruction of the power centres of the Palestinian security system. And this Thursday, he essentially declared war on the Palestinian Authority with the intention of neutralising Mr Arafat.

Mr Arafat is apparently willing to achieve his national objectives either by peaceful means or by violence, just as when he showed up at a United Nations meeting in 1974 holding both a gun and an olive branch. During the Oslo process, he put down his gun and was prepared for se curity co-operation with Israel. When he became disillusioned, he was willing to pick up the gun again.

Each escalation of violence has fuelled the next. Mr Arafat's periodic instructions for a ceasefire were not unequivocal. But Mr Sharon did not accept Mr Arafat's cease-fire declaration of December 16 last year, which was largely implemented. He has rejected the Saudi initiative that promises normal relations with Israel in exchange for the withdrawal of Israel from the territories it occupied in 1967. And he seems to interpret the low American profile on the crisis so far as a green light for making war, just as he did in Lebanon 20 years ago.

The only way out of this crisis is for the two sides to agree to a ceasefire to be supervised by the United States, build on the Saudi initiative and use the help of the American mediator, General Anthony Zinni, to ensure that the Palestinian Authority's security forces are restored. Implementation of existing agreements and resumption of peace talks are essential.

The Israeli war against the terrorist infrastructure will give birth to more terrorists because the terrorist infrastructure lies within people's hearts. It can be uprooted only if there is hope for a different kind of life in the Middle East. I believe a different life is still possible, but each day that passes without some gesture by both sides toward that future makes peace ever more elusive.

·Yossi Beilin was justice minister in the government of Ehud Barak.