I agree with Mr McGrath re the mechanicals in MND. I haven't studied all the threads, but if I remember my A-level history correctly (and I may not because it was a long time ago), professional, secular, play-acting only developed in England from the 16th century onwards. Before that it would have been mystery and other plays eg on classical themes performed by amateurs for local audiences for special occasions. I can't believe that Shakespeare dreamt up Peter Quince's production of Pyramus and Thisbe out of pure imagination.

I also side with the view that it's the activity rather than the text that is the essence of Mummers' plays. The Herga Mummers certainly ad lib from year to year - partly because of failing memory but also to incorporate current topical references.

Kitty