The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #49896   Message #755352
Posted By: GUEST,Alex
27-Jul-02 - 01:57 AM
Thread Name: Garnet Rogers, A Made Man...
Subject: RE: Garnet Rogers, A Made Man...
Clinton, Valerie has explained that this is a sampler rather than a "hits" release. It is titled "All That Is" NOT "GARNET ROGERS GREATEST HITS" as you imply. Many folk artists with several albums do this in order to promote their careers. From your reply I conclude that you are sourly launching a personal attack on a folk artist held in high regard by many fans in Canada, the USA and Europe. Your comments do not in any way constitute artistic criticism of the album. I suggest you withdraw and offer an apology. (BTW According to mafia rules he is not a "made man" until he actually kills somebody.)

To Joe Offer: I was under the impression that personal attacks were not sanctioned on the Mudcat. I realize that it took Clinton several posts before he admitted that this was personal.