The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #51408   Message #786809
Posted By: McGrath of Harlow
18-Sep-02 - 01:27 PM
Thread Name: BS: Is 9/11 overworked?
Subject: RE: BS: Is 9/11 overworked?
"another member here decided to take issue with my referring to the Twin Towers atrocity as *mass murder* and tried to make the misplaced *moral equivalency* case for the bombings of Dresden,Hiroshima

You sure about that, Teribus? As I recall it the post you refer to was making the point that September 11 wasn't an act of war, it was an act of murder; and that since acts of mass killing in war, such as Hiroshima and Dresden, aren't counted as murder, but as acts of war, calling September 11 an act of war serves in a way to give it a respect it doesn't deserve.

That's not a point I agree with (acts of war in my view can often be criminal, and I look forward to an effective International War Crimes Court, so that maybe that won't just be applied against the people who lose the wars) - but if my recollection is correct, thebwriter wasn't objectomh to September 11 being desrcibed as "mass murder", but to it being dignified with the term "an act of war".