Dear Parafantastic Mudlark SS...

"Not Jesse James; try an outlaw who "was born in Indiana.""

How about Earl Butz????

Honestly now, I've spent hours researching Indiana's Infamous and have come up with a list as long as my arm, which includes John Dillinger, Dick Yaeger, Johnny Ringo, the Dangerous Dunn Bros (Del and Bee), 6-shooter Jack and possibly Billy the Kid, among others. After a long look at the Secret Santa signup list, I'm still wandering around in the dark. I am on tenterhooks!