The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #43943   Message #897876
Posted By: mg
24-Feb-03 - 10:08 PM
Thread Name: blue books revisited (Rise Up Singing)
Subject: RE: blue books revisited (Rise Up Singing)
I think the problem isn't so much with people using the blue books, but trying to make everyone else, and really really slowing down the rhythm while they make sure everyone turns to a page. And they shove the books at you too. I'm not fond of the music words handed out before the singing either. Say you have them and let people take them after, or before, or during, if they can do it quickly. And know the group....if they are all equally beginners, I still think they can find songs they know..Red River Valley, Home on the range..that sort of stuff. If they are really good you will drive them crazy with the blue books and they will leave most likely and not come back and the music experience will be greatly diminished. The social experience might be stronger thougn. So if you are going for a social experience it doesn't matter but if you are going for a musical experience it does. Pick your poison. And people can always hum along, read lips, etc. Sing choruses....mg