The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #58010   Message #915671
Posted By: greg stephens
21-Mar-03 - 06:04 PM
Thread Name: Who or what are the 'Folk Police'
Subject: RE: Who or what are the 'Folk Police'
It's seems to be peculiar to the folk scene, people trying to pass off other kinds of music as "folk", and calling people who obect "folk police". I think it quite unlikely that anybody would go to a rock'n'roll night with their choir and do a Purcell motet, and then object if someone said "Very nice, but's not very rock'n'roll". People might love it, but that wouldn't make it rock'n'roll, and it would not be considered a "fascist" or "police" comment if you pointed it out.
    I don't know why this is, there must be a psychological explanation. I play all sorts of music, but if I'm playing something that isn't folk I feel no wild urge to convince people that it is. Even if I strum a guitar while I sing it.
   I presume it is basically the inherent strength of actual folk music that generates this problem: people who love folk music feel a desparate desire that whatever music they make must be folk music too; and they can't bear it if some "Emperor's New Clothes" type boy says"But it ISNT folk".