BillD, Thank you. Very well put. I don't think it would work very well, though to have separate forum as we have so much thread creep when someone asks for a song and others respond with their experiences with it, history of it, etc. That just naturally leads to more discussion, one of the great things about this forum.

I understand about the song circles; if we were actually able to be singing together on here, well, first off...it would be HEAVEN! Second, we'd probably be more likely not to digress and respectful of any parameters set.

I am glad you made note of the lack of info re' Gargoyle. I thought about starting a thread about those personal attacks, but decided lack of attention was probably a better response.

So, here, I guess I've answered some of my own BS about why I started this thread. We will always have controversy, hopefully we can keep on a civil and non-personal level.

katlaughing