The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #60852   Message #975128
Posted By: Thomas the Rhymer
02-Jul-03 - 09:44 AM
Thread Name: Classical Training
Subject: Classical Training
Some here would say, that the notes carry meaning
And others there are who must notate their gleaning
While contestants audition, backstabbing permission
The folk process lives without sophisticate leaning

So, I am courteously wondering just how you feel about the 'classical' approach to folk and traditional music... I am constantly in awe of the sheer mastery and convenience of an instantly read tune... and yet, somehow... this 'freeze dried' version of heartfelt songs... though well preserved... is somewhat lacking in freshness...

...and what's worse, is the implicite denial of deeper substance... by some of the very people who 'profess' to know it so well...

What are your thoughts on this question?

Does the 'classical' approach to folk and traditional music detract from..., or enrich the underlying musical passion?

With much intrinsic questioning, ttr