Peter T., I didn't read any reviews of "Gods and Generals" but I did read the book. All I really know about it is that the movie is supposed to be really long and that there is an intermission. Besides, I really do prefer to make up my own mind, not simply accept what a reviewer says.

Back in 1991 or so I was on a committee to decide what were the "Notable Books" of the year. There was one book I thoroughly enjoyed and thought it was outstanding -- and I gave it the only vote it got; I got the "you don't know squat about good books" look from other members of the committee. No, I'm not going to mention titles or organizations, but all but one of the books they finally listed as "Notable" I found "arty".

I don't object at all to good art, or even poor art done honestly. I object to ANY art form that takes itself sooooooooooooo seriously that it no longer has internal structure and discipline or a sense of fun.