|
|||||||
Lyr Req: Jack Haggerty DigiTrad: FLAT RIVER GIRL JACK HAGGERTY (2) JACK HAGGERTY (3) Related threads: come all ye bold raftsmen/jack haggerty (3) (origins) Origins: John Hackety / Jack Haggerty (26) harmonica on mick hanleys jack haggerty (17) Lyr/Chords Req: Jack Hagerty? / Jack Haggerty (4) (closed) Chords Req: Jack Haggerty (2) |
Share Thread
|
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: GUEST,hg Date: 14 Mar 01 - 10:21 PM ...I appreciate your scholarship, rich. I am continually impressed with your research and always look for your posts. I still love the music aspect of the forum... thanks for keeping it alive...hg |
Subject: Lyr Add: FLAT RIVER GIRL (from Beck) From: raredance Date: 15 Apr 01 - 01:45 PM Another lumberjack song thread reminded me I wasn't finished here. FLAT RIVER GIRL (Beck "Lore of the Lumber Camps" version E, from Mrs. Alice S Vaughan opf Greenville, MI. Mrs Vaughan got her version of the song from John Tucker, the brother of Anne Tucker Mercer)
1. I'm a heartbroken raftsman, from Greenville I came. This is a fairly complete version without many unusual phrases. We do discover that Anna had brown eyes, she went to the suppers and dances, but just regular rides, no boat rides. there is a little extra geography, as he is known from "Six Lakes to Greenville". He has also taken to engraving his name on the lake, even more ephemeral than the sand. I choose not to comment on the "Farewell to Flat River, and the gay girls behind" line. happy easter rich r |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: GUEST,harpgirl Date: 15 Apr 01 - 06:56 PM Interesting variation Rich. I think verses four and six seem to change the song alot.. Jack becomes a dandy rather than a river rat. I like it when he engraves his name on the "high rocks on/f shore". I did it myself all around the North Channel and Georgian Bay when I was a girl...harpgrrrl |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: raredance Date: 15 Apr 01 - 08:37 PM Good point to make, although I think I would argue that verses 4 & 5 of Beck "D", immediately preceding, express pretty much the same sentiments. Maybe dapper Jack lurks in both of those. Georgian Bay in L Huron? Good you're not one of those red-eyed Wiarton girls. rich r |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: harpgirl Date: 15 Apr 01 - 08:40 PM yup...red eyed Wiarton girls????? |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: raredance Date: 15 Apr 01 - 10:15 PM Drift warning! Sorry for being obscure, it'a a line from "White Squall" by Stan Rogers rich r |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: harpgirl Date: 25 Feb 02 - 12:19 AM |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: Murray MacLeod Date: 25 Feb 02 - 01:53 AM The tune that Touchstone sing this to (composed by Mick Hanly ?) is the same as Brian McNeill used for "The Back of the North Wind*. Murray
|
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: Naemanson Date: 25 Feb 02 - 10:00 AM This is all very well but there are no chords for any of these versions. I have only heard the Touchstone version but these others all look inviting to me. Which one do we have the chords for? And if it isn't the Touchstone version then I guess the midi file needs to be added also. This is a little like the old books where the collector faithfully writes down the lyrics of the songs but say little to nothing about the tune. For those of us who don't write music these books are fascinating from an intellectual point of view but little help if we want to sing the songs. Thanks for the thread, by the way. I don't want to leave anyone with the impression that I don't appreciate what has been said so far. As with most of the human race, I just want more. |
Subject: RE: Jack Haggerty From: raredance Date: 25 Feb 02 - 11:12 PM The old books are not without their tune lines. Cazden et al. "Folk Songs of the Catskills"; Doerflinger, "Songs of the Sailor and Lumbermen"; Glass & Singer "Songs of Forest and River Folk"; Peters, "Folk Songs Out of Wisconsin"; Fowke, "Lumbering Songs from the Northern Woods"; Gardner & Chickering "Ballads and Songs of Southern Michigan" all contain a melody line. Beck "Lore of the Lumber Camp" has 2 tunes. Beck's tunes are reprinted in Goodin, "Sounds of the Lake and Forest, Michigan Folk Songs". Rickaby "Ballads and Songs of the Shanty-Boy" has 3 tunes (one of which is the same as one of Beck's). A version has been recorded by Paul Calyton on "Timber-r-r! Folksongs and Ballds of the Lumberjack" (1957, Riverside RLP 12-648). clayton, in turn, says his version is based on a Library of Congress recording by John Norman of Michigan. rich r |
Share Thread: |
Subject: | Help |
From: | |
Preview Automatic Linebreaks Make a link ("blue clicky") |