Subject: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: RonU Date: 04 Feb 98 - 12:09 AM I know this seems perhaps insignificant but here goes anyway. In the song "Streets of Laredo (the cowboy's lament)" there is the line where the young cowboy was all wrapped in white linen. I don't get it, never did. Originally before I had seen all the words, I thought he was already dead but, the words in the database make it clear he died after telling his sad story. What gives ?? |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: leprechaun Date: 04 Feb 98 - 12:50 AM I always thought of it as a shroud, or something they wrap him in before they stuff him in a coffin. Sort of like a cotton bag you wrap around a deer or elk carcass to keep the flies out. I think the idea that he dies after the song is just a matter of poetic license. Mothers don't let your babies grow up to be turtle boys. I've got to make it to Rose's back door. But I'll be better, Doc, as soon as I am able. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Susan-Marie Date: 04 Feb 98 - 08:33 AM Yeah, he must be dead, because in addition to being wrapped in a shroud, he's "cold as the clay". I always figured he was a ghost, which is why he could be dead but singing the song. Or maybe the writer was looking at the deceased young man, imagining what he would say if he could talk. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Bruce O. Date: 04 Feb 98 - 10:35 AM He originally died in Ireland. Irish broadsides of the song, c 1800, are "The Unfortuante Rake" and "The Buck's Elegy". It was the mercury given him to control his syphilis that killed him. I can't remember whether the mercury was in the form of calomel or corrosive sublimate (chlorides of mercury). Susan of DT? |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Jon W. Date: 04 Feb 98 - 11:01 AM I searched the database and found several versions including parodies but nothing like the original "Unfortunate Rake." Anyone care to submit it? |
Subject: Lyr Add: THE BUCK'S ELEGY From: Bruce O. Date: 04 Feb 98 - 12:02 PM [This version is obviously a bit corrupt. 2nd and 3rd verses don't agree about the mercury.]
The Buck's Elegy
As I was walking down Covent Garden,
Had I but known what his disorder was,
Doctors take away your mercury bottles,
When I am dead wrap me up in funeral fine,
There is Capt.---, and likewise Capt. Townsend.
Come bumble your drums, bumble them with crapes of black, From Holloway and Black, 'Later English broadside Ballads', I, #17, where references to traditional versions of the British Isles are given. I don't seem to have a copy of "The Unfortunate Rake" version. The Irish tune "The Unfortunate Rake" is in Crosby's 'Irish Musical Repository', but it does not sound to me to be at all related to America tunes to "Tom Sherman's Barroom", "St. James Infirmary (or Hospital)" or "Streets of Loredo", that I have heard.
|
Subject: Tune Add: THE UNFORTUNATE RAKE From: Bruce O. Date: 04 Feb 98 - 12:48 PM All but last d are sharpened, but even if last were, the tune would not be one of the 7 normal 'Greek' modes. I have not found the tune elsewhere under any title. 'Theme code' is 51H2H4 11H2H5.
|
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Bill in Alabama Date: 04 Feb 98 - 02:06 PM "Streets of Laredo" is an American adaption of an English ballad (a broadside, I seem to recall). I can't remember the title: I believe that it's called "When I Was a Soldier," or "The Soldier's Lament." Maddy Prior did a fine job with it on one of the Steeleye Span albums, and even the tune was basically unchanged. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: RonU Date: 04 Feb 98 - 11:27 PM Looks to me like the dead Irishman was talking (or singing), also. |
Subject: Lyr Add: DYING OUTFIT ('Streets of Laredo' parody) From: rich r Date: 09 Feb 98 - 10:54 PM THE DYING OUTFIT
As I walked out in the streets of Laredo,
I see by your outfit that you are a cowboy.
Now you got no outfit, so you're not a cowboy.
You fit in my outfit. I fit in your outfit.
As I walked out in the streets of Laredo, A version of this was recorded by Tom & Dick Smothers rich r |
Subject: Lyr Add: STREETS OF LAREDO (corrected verse) From: rich r Date: 09 Feb 98 - 11:26 PM OK so I cannot spell "Wlaked", at least I'm consistently inconsistent. I noticed in the DT that the 2nd line of verse 11 or 12 of "Streets of Laredo" apparently dropped in by mistake from some other song. The verse should be:
Get six jolly cowboys to carry my coffin The long version of the song in DT is the same as "The Cowboy's Lament" published in 1908 in Songs of the Cowboys by N Howard "Jack" Thorp. Thorp writes, "Authorship credited to Troy Hale, Battle Creek, Nebraska. I first heard it sung in a bar-room at Wisner, Nebraska, about 1886." rich r |
Subject: Lyr Add: ST. JAMES HOSPITAL (from A. L. Lloyd) From: Paul Stamler Date: 10 Feb 98 - 12:50 AM Another version of the song is "St. James' Hospital", which makes it sound as though he's being wrapped in linen (or, in some versions, flannel) because he has the shivers. Here are the lyrics as recorded by A. L. Lloyd: As I was out walking by St. James' hospital I was out walking down by there one day I spied a young man all wrapped in white linen All wrapped in white linen, though warm was the day. I asked him what ailed him, I asked him what failed him I asked him the cause of all his complaint "It's all on account of some handsome young woman 'Tis she that has caused me to weep and lament" "And had she but told me before she disordered me Had she but told me of it in time I might have got pills or salts of white mercury But now I'm cut down in the height of me prime." "Get six young soldiers to carry me coffin Six young girls to sing me a song And have each of them carry a bunch of green laurel So they can't smell me as they bear me along." "And don't muffle your drums, me jewel, me joy Play your fife merry as you bear me along And fire your bright muskets all over me coffin Sayin', 'There goes an unfortunate lad to his home'." It was recorded on Lloyd's Topic album "First Person", and has been reissued on the superb Fellside CD "Classic A. L. Lloyd". Peace. Paul |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Rick---obaoighill@earthlink.net Date: 10 Feb 98 - 02:40 AM Another version of the song above appears on Christy Moore's "Prosperous". It is entitled "Locke Hospital" and it tells the tale of a young soldier who dies of a sexually transmitted disease. On that note... Slainte Rick |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Jerry Friedman Date: 10 Feb 98 - 01:42 PM Maybe you know this, Bruce, but that D# makes it "harmonic minor" instead of "natural minor". If there were C's and some of them were sharped too (especially when they came before D#'s), it would be "melodic minor", like "Greensleeves". I like harmonic minor because it sounds Jewish. In fact, that extra-long step between the 6th and 7th degrees has been called the "Jewish third". |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Bruce O. Date: 10 Feb 98 - 01:56 PM Harmonic and melodic minors seem to me to be uncommon, but also, I think ABC only recognizes the 7 normal 'Greek' modes. I have even used phoney keys in ABC to get the right number of sharps or flats on the key signature for a few tunes, so don't take the specified key litterally. The actual keynote in ABC will be the real one you enter in in spite of what the key signature mayn say. [Those that are unfamiliar with harmonic and melodic minors might consult the tune coding section near the end of Herrmann and Huntington's 'Sam Henry's Songs of the People'. I think this is taken from Bertrand Bronson, but I don't have his publications on the subject] |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Susan of DT Date: 10 Feb 98 - 06:55 PM Searching for most of these "Unfortunate Rake" variants show up a DT #350. Then search for #350 to find 8 variants already in the database. Thanx for the additional ones. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Charlie Baum Date: 10 Feb 98 - 07:41 PM While we're on the subject of "St. James Hospital", I've been searching for a recording I once heard on the radio (WPKN-FM in Bridgeport, CT) of Doc Watson singing it a cappella (as opposed to the recordings where he accompanies himself on guitar, which I already have). Can anyone supply me with the name of the album containing the version I'm seeking? Thanks. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Paul Stamler Date: 11 Feb 98 - 02:21 AM Doc's version appears on his first Vanguard album, "Doc Watson" (Vanguard VSD-79152). Don't know if it was reissued on "The Vanguard Years". He may also have recorded it elsewhere. Peace. Paul |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Paul Stamler Date: 11 Feb 98 - 01:27 PM Uh, whoops, let me correct myself. The version on "Doc Watson" (Vanguard) may be accompanied by guitar. I don't have it here, so can't check. But the version on "Live and Pickin'" (United Artists UA-LA-943-H, 1979) is a capella; it's combined with an instrumental, "Frosty Morn". Peace. Paul |
Subject: Lyr Add: STREETS OF LAREDO (parody) From: Joe Offer Date: 25 May 98 - 12:42 AM This one always seems bring a little cheer when people are grouchy. It's a favorite in our song circle in Sacramento. It may pre-date the Smothers Brothers rendition. -Joe Offer- STREETS OF LAREDO (Parody by Milt & Marge Lev and Walt Robertson, with help from a very large bottle of wine) As I walked out on the streets of Laredo, As I walked out in Laredo one day, I spied a young cowboy all wrapped in white linen All wrapped in white linen as cold as the clay. I see by your outfit that you are a cowboy You see by my outfit that I am one too We see by our outfits that we are both cowboys For I have an outfit and you have one too. My outfit fits neatly; it's a neat-fitting outfit Your white linen neat-fitting outfit fits you So we are two cowboys in white linen outfits White linen outfits that fit neatly too. When I'm out of my outfit, I am not a cowboy When you're out of your outfit, then neither are you But we're both fit out in our neat-fitting outfits So I am a cowboy and you are one too. Let's see if your neat-fitting outfit will fit me Let's see if my neat-fitting outfit fits you If my outfit fits you and your outfit fits me Then we can trade outfits and they will fit too. As the outfitted cowboys were trading their outfits Their neat-fitting outfits of white linen hue An outlaw passed by in his black outlaw outfit And spied the two cowboys and shot up the two. As I walked out on the streets of Laredo, As I walked out in Laredo one day, I spied two dead cowboys all wrapped in white linen All wrapped in white linen as cold as the clay. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Will Date: 25 May 98 - 09:49 AM Peter Beagle (author of "The Last Unicorn" and several other books of fantasy) wrote a lovely book about him and a friend riding scooters from New York to the Bay Area in the early 1960s, called "I See By My Outfit". A recurrent theme is him singing the title-line to his friend. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Cuilionn Date: 25 May 98 - 02:16 PM Och, ye've given me a richt guid laugh wi' a' yer outfittin'... Jist thocht I'd drap a wee line in tae mention that Eric Bogle's sang "No Man's Land" (alsae ca'd "Willie McBride") brings in th' same chorus as a' th' ither versions, tho' it jostles it aroond a wee bit.
An beannachd ort,
--Cuilionn |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Joe Offer Date: 25 May 98 - 03:29 PM With typing like that, Cuilionn, one might think you were Shula. I never figured out how she could type dialect without going bonkers. -Joe Offer- |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Tim Jaques tjaques@netcom.ca Date: 25 May 98 - 06:29 PM Where is Shula these days, anyway? 1. The Steeleye Span version was called "When I Was On Horseback." I assume it is an Irish version because it mentions Cork City, but I never did figure out the significance of the soldier being killed on the 14th of May. 2. Another version is from woman's point of view, and is called The Unfortunate Lass. There are versions of this from eastern Canada. 3. It would be an interesting, if somewhat depressing CD, to collect different variants of this song. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Joe Offer Date: 25 May 98 - 07:12 PM Hi, Tim - Shula's been sick, but she dropped in last week to say that she's doing pretty well. The various versions of this song are linked in the database, and you can find them all by searching for #350. The notes for When I Was On Horseback say that an album of these songs is available on the Folkways label. -Joe Offer- |
Subject: Lyr Add: BALLAD OF SHERMAN WU (Pete Seeger) From: Art Thieme Date: 27 May 98 - 10:52 AM Pete Seeger sang this on one of his BROADSIDE LPs for Folkways. BALLAD OF SHERMAN WU
As I roved out on the streets of Northwestern,
"I see by your frat pin that you are a Psi U,
The dean said, "Now Sherman, don't raise a commotion,
Art Thieme
|
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Debbie Date: 27 May 98 - 03:58 PM I believe Marty Robins also recorded a version of this one, but it's slightly different, i don't recognise some of the verses, and he sings some other verses.... Debs |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: pavane Date: 06 Aug 01 - 03:36 AM I don't see The Royal Albion mentioned - another member of the group of songs, but unfortunately I don't have the words to hand. Very similar though, as I remember it. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Kim C Date: 06 Aug 01 - 11:26 AM Oh, heavens.... everytime I sing Streets of Laredo I think about that damn Outfit thing..... :-D |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Greg F. Date: 06 Aug 01 - 12:46 PM and then there'sTHIS |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: The Walrus at work Date: 06 Aug 01 - 01:14 PM Bruce,
I'd tend to agree with the other versions quoted that Regards Walrus
|
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: GUEST,DaisyA Date: 06 Aug 01 - 02:22 PM There is a lovely version of St James' Hospital on Kate and Anna McGarrigle's Heartbeats Accelerating. It's the last track - really wonderful. Daisy |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: LR Mole Date: 06 Aug 01 - 02:47 PM Misinformation? Someone once told me VD is called "clap" because the mercury treatment is so painful that people receiving it would be slapped to distract them. Interesting thing to put on one's resume. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: CRANKY YANKEE Date: 06 Aug 01 - 02:52 PM "A Sailor Cut Down in His Prime" predates (I think) the streets of Laredo. Pretty Much the same melody. It starts....... As I was walking down by the Royal Albion. If anyone is interested in this, send me a PM and I'll dig it out for you. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: pavane Date: 06 Aug 01 - 04:20 PM White Copper (old name for mercury) is mentioned in the song Lass of London City, which is another song in a similar vein. 'As I was a walking down White Copper Alley'. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Chicken Charlie Date: 06 Aug 01 - 05:43 PM If one may be allowed to return to the original question .... Two possibilities occur. One is that it's a fossil leftover from the Irish version, in the context of which it might have made better sense. Second is that cowboys and Western travellers in general sometimes wore an outer garment called a "duster" which was a very thin overcoat designed to protect one's clothes from trail dust, whence the name. I believe dusters were often light colored if not truly white, and generally made of linen so as to be more easily washable. CC |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Liz the Squeak Date: 06 Aug 01 - 05:50 PM I always thought he was a ghost, trying to warn the cowboy, like ghosts usually do.... why can't ghosts just let us get on with it? LTS |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: katlaughing Date: 06 Aug 01 - 05:54 PM As in a winding sheet? That's what I always thought it was. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: DougR Date: 06 Aug 01 - 06:49 PM I think of it as a shroud, as many others of you do, and the narrator as a ghost. In Burl Ives song book he merely notes that it is a "variant on an Irish song, "The Unfortunate Rake." DougR |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: CRANKY YANKEE Date: 06 Aug 01 - 11:40 PM Is it REALLY that important? |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: artbrooks Date: 06 Aug 01 - 11:43 PM For what its worth...which probably isn't much...there's also a version I learned in Seattle about a seasick Norwegen fisherman called "Streets of Stavanger". Uff da. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: GUEST,Fred Date: 07 Aug 01 - 11:41 PM For what it's worth, the tune is from the Irish song The Bard of Armagh. I also always assumed that the cowboy was wrapped up for burying, but I never thought of him as a ghost. I guess I never stopped to wonder why he would already be wrapped for burying before he was actually dead. Love the parodies. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Sorcha Date: 07 Aug 01 - 11:53 PM I always thought of it as a "left over" from the original St. James Infirmary song----the guy has syphillis so they give him salts of mercury to raise his body temperature to kill the spirochetes; then they wrap him in linen to increase the rise in body temperature.
After that, they put him on the roof of St. James to lie in the sunshine........and WHOOPS!! too much heat, so he cooks to death.
None of that really makes sense with the US cowboy version of Streets of Laredo but ballads often don't make sense when they are transferred from another culture.
The US cowboy version seems to be using the "white linen" as a shroud even though the boy isn't quite dead yet, but he is wrapped for burial and has Final Requests.......the 6 cowboys, maidens, etc. He KNOWS he is going to die and that he is wrapped for burial. just my $0.02 worth |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Haruo Date: 20 Jan 02 - 09:41 PM Just posted La Stratoj Laredaj (Esperanto translation by Marta Evans, slightly revised by me) in La Lilandejo; would be interested in other non-English versions of "The Streets of Laredo". Liland PS The white linen is there (though only once, not repeated as in English), but the difference I find most striking is the seven (not six) pallbearers, maidens and roses ("luckiest number at dice for a bet"). |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Nerd Date: 20 Jan 02 - 10:48 PM Someone mentions that it would be neat for a CD to be compiled of the versions of this song. This was done on LP by folklorist Kenny Goldstein in the 1960s. It was a folkways LP with scholarly notes and about twenty variants (including, I think, Sherman Wu) of the song. Like all folkways LPs, this can be ordered as a custom-Burned CD from Smithsonian Folkways. The title is The Unfortunate Rake. The notes give a complete run-down on the song's history (1st recorded text, etc) and the singers are an interesting mix of professional folksingers (the late Wade Hemsworth is on it, as is Rosalie Sorrels) and folklorists (including Goldstein, Roger Abrahams, Jan Brunvand, Alan Lomax). Not the best listening ever, but an interesting album |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Amos Date: 20 Jan 02 - 11:05 PM Jeeze-- they used linen for bandages too -- the guy was shot in the breast, obviously seriously, and he'd be cold as the clay from loss of blood without a shroud coming into it. It's just BANDAGES folks!! Let's stay as real as possible under the circumstances. They don't let the winding sheet committee in until someone says, "He's dead, Jim...." A |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: CapriUni Date: 20 Jan 02 - 11:15 PM I guess what confuses people, Amos, is the phrase "All wrapped..." which suggests that it was head to foot. But that word could simply be in the line for scansion reasons And then, there is another version in the DT, here. The first two verses make it clear that he is still alive, and was left in the street deliberately, and the people who did the wrapping (either bandages or shrowd) were on the run. |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: DougR Date: 20 Jan 02 - 11:21 PM Anybody else checked out the thread of old music Rick posted in another thread of singers from the twenties and thirties singing this song. I heard three different versions of the tune of this song there. I wasn't familiar with any of them. DougR |
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Rolfyboy6 Date: 20 Jan 02 - 11:21 PM Does anybody know how St. James Hospital got transformed into St. James Infirmary (Blues)? The feel of the words is late ragtime/early jazz/early blues. St. James Infirmary The D.T. lyrics are a little stilted in comparison to how it's usually sung.
|
Subject: RE: ...all wrapped in white linen. From: Dicho (Frank Staplin) Date: 20 Jan 02 - 11:52 PM Put The Cowboy's Lament in the DT and up comes Harry Jackson's version of the Streets of Laredo, where no less than 16 cowboys are called for to carry the coffin and 16 pretty ladies to bear up the pall. The cowboy was from southeast Texas; a Texas-sized funeral is expected. Type in Lament, and up comes "Streets of Laredo (Cowboy's Lament)" where only six of each are required. The boy's people came from the Nation (Indian Territory) so he was probably Injun and wouldn't expect many to come to his funeral. Folks, the two cowboys were not the same. This explains the confusion. Liland, where did the seventh man position himself to carry the pall? |
Share Thread: |
Subject: | Help |
From: | |
Preview Automatic Linebreaks Make a link ("blue clicky") |