To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=124208
8 messages

BS: Irish history help - please!

08 Oct 09 - 08:30 PM (#2741616)
Subject: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: Michael Harrison

I've read recently that Henry VIII is responsible for making the "harp" the symbol of Ireland and I'll accept that as true from the author I am currently reading. My question is: did those from beyond the pale ever agree that it should be so, or did they just accept the dictate from the slimy Tudor King and let it go at that; or, did the Irish never accept it?

I've worn the harp for several years now and the thought of it not being a "true" symbol of Ireland would lead me to cease wearing it. So, how and when did the harp become the symbol of Ireland, or, is it really not the symbol of Ireland? I'm so confused.
Thanks. Cheers,.........mwh


08 Oct 09 - 08:34 PM (#2741620)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: Rapparee

It's as much -- perhaps more -- of a symbol for Ireland as the shamrock, the shillelagh or the pint of Guinness.


08 Oct 09 - 08:36 PM (#2741624)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: Peace

Henry VIII began the use of it on coins in about 1525-1530.


08 Oct 09 - 08:48 PM (#2741631)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: Joe Offer

This p;age has some nice information. This page says the harp as a distinctive symbol of Ireland was introduced on the coinage by Henry VIII around 1526. The fact that Henry VIII used it on coins, doesn't mean that it's a horrible thing to use a harp as a symbol for Ireland. It was symbolic of Ireland long before Henry made it official.

-Joe-


08 Oct 09 - 09:16 PM (#2741645)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: robomatic

I saw somewhere that the harp is an ancient symbol for Israel, though the symbol I saw was different from the Irish harp, more symmetrical.


08 Oct 09 - 10:34 PM (#2741674)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: Michael Harrison

Joe, thanks for the websites, and thanks, too, to everyone else for their input. I'll hang on to the harp for awhile. Cheers,....mwh


09 Oct 09 - 01:09 AM (#2741754)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: MGM·Lion

As the harp is intimately associated with Irish traditional music, I wonder why this thread was placed below, rather than above, the line?


09 Oct 09 - 09:09 AM (#2741957)
Subject: RE: BS: Irish history help - please!
From: meself

Henry VIII ordained it that way.