To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=157238
66 messages

Book - essays on Irish song

18 May 15 - 04:14 AM (#3709595)
Subject: Folklore: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

In 2007 our local heritage society published a book,' Dear Far Voiced Veteran', in honour of Irish song collector, the late Tom Munnelly - a collection.
It comprised 25 essays (404pp) on mainly Irish - but also Scots, English and one on Indian traditional song, music and dance; among the authors were Nicholas Carolan, Hugh Shields, Fintan Vallely Margaret Bennett, Len Graham, John Moulden, Terry Moylan, David Atkinson.....
It is, as far as I'm concerned, an excellent overview of traditional song and singing, particularly in Ireland
It sold well in Ireland (despite its rather high published price) and more than paid for itself, but due to the cost of postage (a somewhat weighty paperback), it didn't make it abroad to the extent it should have.
The print-run was somewhat over-estimated and we are now left with a considerable number on our hands.
Rather than have them put down humanely, I'm pretty sure our Society would be happy to see them go for the cost of postage and a donation to, say, The Irish Traditional Music Archive in Dublin, of which, Tom Munnelly was one of the founders.
Suggestions wold be welcome
Jim Carrroll


18 May 15 - 02:48 PM (#3709769)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Derek Schofield

I already have a copy of this excellent book. If this is a definite offer, then perhaps post the message to the (UK) Traditional Song Forum etc?
Derek


18 May 15 - 03:34 PM (#3709786)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: MartinRyan

Recommended


18 May 15 - 07:06 PM (#3709826)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Jim I

Where are they, Jim?

I will be in Ireland for 2 weeks from 20th May and could perhaps pick up; thus saving even the postage cost.


18 May 15 - 08:54 PM (#3709848)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: michaelr

I would like to own a copy, Jim. Please PM me about mailing to the US. Thanks!


19 May 15 - 03:28 AM (#3709888)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Will get a price to posting to the U.S. and let you know Michael
At present they are in our loft room in County Clare - (which particular rain-forest you be visiting while you're here Jim I?
For anybody visiting the Willie Clancy Summer School - we live in Miltown Malbay, and I hope to be involved in the singing classes on most days during the week.
Thanks for the suggestion Derek - will try the T.S.F.
Will happily post copies out to people who will pay postage - any donation to ITMA or wherever is up to them - have yet to agree this with the Heritage Society.
As Martin and Derek say - recommended; the articles include:
'From Texts to Work' - (David Atkinson); 'History, Heartbreak and Hope' recording the story behind the song - Newfoundland (Margaret Bennett): Songs in English from the Connemara Gaeltacht (Angela Bourke): 'The Talking Machine Comes to Ireland' (Nicholas Carolan); 'A Simple Countryman?' - Walter Pardon (Pat Mackenzie and Jim Carroll); 'Meeting Child on the Road' Len Graham; 'Collecting Sets in the Early days of the revival' (Terry Moylan); 'Singing the Famine', Joe Heaney (Lillis Ó Laoire and Sean Williams; 'Textual Criticism and Ballad Studies' (Hugh Shields); 'What Did we Singe Before There Were Folk Songs? (John Moulden).....
Fairly wide ranging   
Jim Carroll


19 May 15 - 03:41 AM (#3709895)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

I'd be up for a copy, Jim, and a donation. I used to be a 'friend' of ITMA and knew Nicholas back in the 80s. I used to bring Irish related sheet music over for the collection. You should have my address but if not I'll email you it. How do we pay you for postage? PayPal?


19 May 15 - 05:20 AM (#3709924)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Run-down of postage from here:
Rest of Ireland - €7.00
U.K. €8-30
Ú.S. €11-55
Jim Carroll


19 May 15 - 05:26 AM (#3709925)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

Jim, I would like to buy a copy - can you reserve one for me? Since I'm based in Ireland, could I just send you a cheque? Please either email or PM me the address to post it to. Thanks so much!

Bonnie


19 May 15 - 01:47 PM (#3710042)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

Jim, do you have a PayPal account?


20 May 15 - 04:33 AM (#3710168)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Clive Pownceby

Count me in too Jim - PayPal, as Steve suggests, would be an ideal method of payment. I'm in NW England.


20 May 15 - 07:50 AM (#3710205)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Will sort out the requests over the next few days
Not sure about the state of my PayPal account - around the last time I used it there was a bit of a kerfuffle in the press about privacy and they changed their policy - don't use it enough to have updated mine, but will have a look.
Jim Carroll


20 May 15 - 08:02 AM (#3710212)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Brown

I'd be interested in a copy too, if I can pay by PayPal. I'm in Romania, so I guess that's a different postage rate again.
Jim Brown


20 May 15 - 10:12 AM (#3710261)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

"I guess that's a different postage rate again."
Got an idea that the U.S. rate given is actually an International one - will check
Jim Carroll


20 May 15 - 11:04 AM (#3710278)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Desi C

I'd very much like a copy or two pleas mail me details at crc778@aol.com
Desi


20 May 15 - 12:44 PM (#3710312)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Vic Smith

A copy for me please, Jim.


20 May 15 - 04:56 PM (#3710404)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

Jim, in order to qualify for International Book Rate, the item(s) must weigh a minimum of 3 kilos and a max of 5. And it's more expensive to send to the US than to Britain/Europe. AND - of course - the charges have taken an astronomical hike in a short space of time, well above any rate of inflation or cost-of-living increase.
#whatsnew

http://www.anpost.ie/AnPost/PostalRates/Sending+Books+Abroad.htm


20 May 15 - 06:31 PM (#3710420)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: michaelr

PayPal would be the easiest way for me, but if it's too much trouble on your end, I could mail you a $20 bill.


21 May 15 - 05:58 AM (#3710532)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,matt milton

I'll definitely order a copy. Like others, I'd prefer to use Paypal, but I could post a cheque made payable to whoever you like


21 May 15 - 06:47 AM (#3710548)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Felipa

I'd like to buy a book. I'm in N Ireland.have pay pal account
so how much do I send to who/where? I suppose it's a hefty book, postage U.K. €8-30


21 May 15 - 06:55 AM (#3710550)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Chris Wright

I'd like a copy too, please. PayPal is likewise best for me.

Chris Wright (e-mail: [firstname].[lastname]@ed.ac.uk)


21 May 15 - 06:58 AM (#3710553)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

Folks from outside the Republic should be able to pay internationally by using a SWIFT bank transfer - though it means you'll need Jim's IBAN number (or whichever acronym it is - I get them mixed up).

I sell harp books abroad and have always found this a very satisfactory way of receiving payment. (As if there's an UNsatisfactory way of getting money...)


21 May 15 - 07:05 AM (#3710558)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

There's also a method - at least from the U.K. - known as a BACS payment (they require the receiving bank's sorting/clearing code). Not sure what the difference is, but both work fine for me as recipient. My bank sends me an "Inward Payment" notice when the customer's money has safely landed.


21 May 15 - 06:35 PM (#3710754)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Clive Pownceby

Speaking as a retired banker (ducks to avoid thrown missiles!) BACS -(Bureau Automated Clearing System)would be ideal but Jim would need to trust us with the bank details which Bonnie details. No charge to the sender and via Internet Banking, Jim would have the money in his account, usually within 2 hours.


22 May 15 - 04:31 AM (#3710841)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

BACS appears to be just a U.K. facility (Clive, correct me if I'm wrong!) but SWIFT (Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication) is definitely international. I assume these have replaced stuff like Bank Giro payments?

But Jim would still need to provide bank account details - I'm sure that's going to be the case with any internal transfer.

One could always get a certified bank draft in euro and post it, but I believe it's then negotiable for anybody who might get ahold of it...? Am I right in thinking that they would be as vulnerable as sending cash?

Hope we haven't scared Jim away . . .


22 May 15 - 04:45 AM (#3710843)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

Or does the local heritage society who published this book have a bank account? Then it would at least not be someone's personal details.

I see that Paypal has just paid a huge fine for getting up to some dodgy dealing or other, so I would be wary of using them. I don't anyway, because they're a prime target for scammers. I get loads of fake "Paypal" spam in my inbox, which looks so genuine that I'd be scared of not being able to tell the difference. Only way I know it's phony is that I don't have a Paypal account.


22 May 15 - 11:35 AM (#3710943)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Noreen

Bonnie, just never click on any link in an unsolicited email, even if it looks genuine.


22 May 15 - 12:27 PM (#3710962)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

I deleted them unread, unloved, and unmourned! B x


22 May 15 - 12:38 PM (#3710967)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Noreen

:)


23 May 15 - 04:56 AM (#3711117)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Clive Pownceby

Yup, you're probably more up to speed on financial stuff than I Bonnie! I remember Banking when it was a profession (no, really) - just 'paying in and drawing out' as my first manager told me, and a better world for it!
I digress, but none of us is perfect.
Good to have this connection Ms Shaljean, - remember those Bothy gigs in the '70s at the Blundell Arms?
Okay Mudcatters I'll get back on track!


28 May 15 - 03:31 PM (#3712579)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

Refresh.
Any news?


28 May 15 - 03:55 PM (#3712585)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Richard Mellish

One for me too, please. In my case it's probably easiest to post euro cash. Address to send that to?

Richard


28 May 15 - 07:46 PM (#3712649)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

In hand - sorry - up to my eyes (really working against a deadline at present)
If anyone wants to send money in post (Sterling or Euro) it might speed things up a little.
As soon as I have confirmation that they are happy to do this and let me have an address, book will go in post (already sent one off)
Sorry for delay
Jim Carroll


29 May 15 - 11:35 AM (#3712814)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

Are you OK for a cheque in Euro, drawn on an Irish bank? Made out to... ?

I really don't want to send cash


29 May 15 - 11:44 AM (#3712819)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Fine Bonnie - make out to J Carroll
Missed the post today - will go in Tuesday (Bank Holiday)
Jim


29 May 15 - 04:45 PM (#3712898)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Bonnie Shaljean

Can you PM or email me your address? You already have mine, but I can send it to you again if you want. Cheers!


31 May 15 - 08:31 AM (#3713354)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Clive Pownceby

I'd be happy to take a chance on posting cash Jim. Could you email me on jean@pownceby.fsnet.co.uk
address and amount required? - Euros or sterling.


01 Jun 15 - 05:19 AM (#3713561)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Clive Pownceby

Thanks for prompt reply Jim. The cash (marking a change from the mythical 'cheque') is in the post!


01 Jun 15 - 09:04 AM (#3713617)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

Cheque in post this morning.


01 Jun 15 - 09:47 AM (#3713627)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Steve
Need postal address - hope to put some in post tomorrw
You have my e-mail address, I think
Goesfor anybody who hasn't given me one.
You have a morning post?
"Cardboard box - you were lucky!!"
Jim Carroll


01 Jun 15 - 12:00 PM (#3713657)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

Jim,
I sent you my address on the first email and it's with the cheque but I'll send it again anyway.


01 Jun 15 - 12:03 PM (#3713659)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

Can't believe it!
Just tried to post a message on the Bell Accordeon thread about 10 times unsuccessfully, meantime I had a go at the above post and went up straight away. Crazy!


08 Jun 15 - 12:54 PM (#3715259)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Sorry for the delay folks - back in the land of the living.
Posted a batch of books off today and will do some more as soon as I have addresses from those who want them so can all that definitely want them, let me know
Jim Brown - postage to Romania from Ireland is the same as to Britain - €8.50 (surprised me, might wrap myself in a parcel and send myself - always wanted to go)

The postal rates again, as I have them
Ireland €7.00
England €8.30
U.S.A. €11.55
Thomas Stern - found postal costs for parcel 3 - €36.50 (sorry 'bout that) so it's cheaper to send them separately rather than in one parcel.
Will e-mail those who have sent contact address
Sorry for the delay
Jim Carroll


09 Jun 15 - 03:50 AM (#3715393)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Refresh


11 Jun 15 - 07:34 AM (#3715979)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Clive Pownceby

Arrived safely today Jim. Many thanks.


11 Jun 15 - 03:28 PM (#3716081)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: michaelr

One Andrew Jackson in the mail! Thanks, Jim, it looks to be a very interesting read.


11 Jun 15 - 04:16 PM (#3716087)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST

A very kind offer, and I'd be happy to pay the post and a donation: but to whom? As an anonymous guest I can't PM you.


12 Jun 15 - 12:14 AM (#3716141)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: michaelr

Well then become a member and Robert is your mum's brother.


12 Jun 15 - 02:52 AM (#3716154)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Guest
Happy to oblige but am reluctant to put up an email address on forum as I've had problems in the past - particularly with B.N.P. hackers being creative with my personal information (rather proud of that one!)
If you don't wish to become a member, forum fairies like Stilly River Sage and Joe Offer have been helpful in the past in passing on information.
Sorry I can't be more helpful than that.
Jim Carroll


12 Jun 15 - 05:56 AM (#3716174)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Vic Smith

Sympathy for Jim, especially as I am another who suffered from identity theft from BNP hackers - or from one particular individual who called himself a 'BNP Attack Dog'. Happily, things seem to have gone quiet on that front of late.


12 Jun 15 - 05:59 AM (#3716175)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Thanks Vic - still need an address for you if you want a copy btw
Jim Carroll


12 Jun 15 - 07:21 AM (#3716186)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Fred McCormick

Vic, that's probably due to the fact that the said organisation has virtually gone out of business, along with its associated attack dogs. Unfortunately, there is still a poster on the Internet somewhere advertising yours truly as one of their candidates. I printed a copy off and put it up on the wall of a pub where we have a monthly singaround.

A bunch of drinkers, whom I hadn't previously taken much notice of, promptly went apoplectic. It turned out the were Italian anti-fascists. Fortunately, before they hacked my goolies off I was able to explain the joke to them and the fact that I'd put it because I was just about to sing an anti-fascist song.

The incident ended amicably, with comradely salutes and what not and before they left, they gave us a rousing rendition of Bandiera Rossa.


12 Jun 15 - 09:15 AM (#3716197)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Vic Smith

Thanks Vic - still need an address for you if you want a copy btw
Jim Carroll


Jim - sent you a PM with those details at 08:57 AM on 11 Jun 2015
Vic


12 Jun 15 - 10:51 AM (#3716207)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

Got mine this morning, Jim. Now doubly in your debt. Many many thanks.


12 Jun 15 - 02:33 PM (#3716241)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: doc.tom

Mine too! Excellent - many thanks Jim


12 Jun 15 - 03:19 PM (#3716244)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: MartinRyan

"What did we singe before..." Lovely! Having gone to the (in)famous Synge Street School in Dublin, I rejoice in the smell of burning... (or "Byrneing" , maybe...)


Regards


23 Jun 15 - 02:40 PM (#3718530)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Vic Smith

A copy arrived in the post today.... before it was even paid for! I made sure that the payment was in the post straight away.
Thank you, Jim.


23 Jun 15 - 02:48 PM (#3718532)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Thank yourself Vic
Jim Carroll


24 Jun 15 - 04:49 AM (#3718635)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: GUEST,Niamh

Jim - can you keep me a copy - I'll see you in Miltown hopefully - otherwise Paypal is easiest for me - best way to send money these days.

Thanks Jim


24 Jun 15 - 06:28 AM (#3718644)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Hi Niamh (Parsons I assume - all the other Niamhs I know only sing when they're drunk!)
Will have them if you are around during the Willie Week, otherwise, I'll bring one to Dublin next time were're there and leave on at The Goilín
I have one more request I have to deal with, so if there are any more, let ae know soon as Irish postal charges are due to go up shortly.
Present rates above
Jim Carroll


24 Jun 15 - 08:04 AM (#3718658)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Vic Smith

The very first song that I sang in a Folk club - it was 1964 in Beckenham - was The Jute Mill Song sung and written by Mary Brooksbank.
In 1969, I was delighted to hear her sing the song in the George Square Theatre in Edinburgh in a concert full of the great Scottish traditional singers. It was organised by the SoSS and compered by Hamish Henderson.
I had the chance to have a short conversation with her at the end of the concert and I was very impressed by her. I knew that she had been a union activist all her life but the only information that I had about her was the interview that the Dundee journalist and writer Maurice Fleming had conducted with her for Chapbook Vol.3, No.4: (1966) and the brief introduction to her book of poems and songs poetry and songs, which she eventually published also in 1966, in a collection called Sidlaw Breezes. The cost of the book was covered by Mary herself, and she lost money on it.

When Michael Marra was preparing a show for the Dundee Rep. on Mary and the jute mills, he was finding it difficult to gather information on her so he contacted me as he knew that I had met her. All that I could do, realistically, was to refer him to the two sources that I have mentioned.

As I wrote in a previous post, the copy of Dear Far Voiced Veteran arrived in the post yesterday. Imagine my delight, therefore, when I started reading it last night and the second article. by Margaret Bennett turned out to be in the main, a transcription of a long and detailed interview of Mary by Hamish in her home on 22nd May 1968. I know now a great deal more about this very important seminal figure than I did previously.

I have a feeling that there are going to be many more delights for me in this book.


24 Jun 15 - 03:18 PM (#3718746)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Before this thread runs its course, can I just draw people's attention to another publication by The Kifarboy Society.
I'm sure most folk buffs are aware of the magnificent work as a full-time collector Tom Munnelly did for U.C.D - many thousands of recordings of songs, tales and lore.
While we were helping sort out his things shortly after his death, we came across six box-files of what we thought were notes to the many lectures Tom gave on his work - they turned out to be scripts - Tom scripted all his talks.
These were digitised from hard copy and the Old Kilfarboy Society has published 15 of them in book form, entitled 'The Singing Will Never Be Done' (collected essays 1990 - 2007)
The subjects include: Tom's own experiences as a collector, Defining excellence, Junior Crehan (fiddle player), Travellers, Love and work songs, emigration, Napoleon.... a literary feast for anybody interested in Irish Traditional culture.
The fact that he gave them as talks (and Tom's own humour and love of the subject) mean they are refreshingly free of academic jargon and impenetrable academicism - a pleasure to read.
Anybody visiting Clare or Dublin can easily purchase a copy, or can order one via OKS
or
eolas@oac.ie
Jim Carroll


25 Jun 15 - 03:34 AM (#3718829)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Mr Red

recent post on the (UK) Trad Music Forum

My 2006 PhD thesis - "The printed ballad in Ireland: a guide to the popular printing of songs in Ireland 1760-1920" is now available at DSpace. It has been assigned the following
identifier:


http://hdl.handle.net/10379/5020

It may be freely downloaded, quoted and cited. Could all citations also include the DSpace identifier?

John Moulden


25 Jun 15 - 03:57 AM (#3718834)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Jim Carroll

Hi John - excellent news, what took you so long??
See you in a couple of weeks in Miltown, maybe?
Best to you both
Jim


25 Jun 15 - 05:22 PM (#3718942)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Steve Gardham

In case anyone is uncertain whether to get a copy of the book Jim is offering I can thoroughly recommend it. One of the most interesting papers (IMHO) is on Walter Pardon's life and songs by Carroll and Mackenzie.


03 Jul 15 - 06:50 AM (#3720724)
Subject: RE: Book - essays on Irish song
From: Vic Smith

Just finished reading it! It is a mighty, informative and stimulating read. I can only second Steve's praise for this varied and fascinating set of essays and add my opinion that anyone with a serious interest in traditional music should be seeking it out.
A big thank you to Jim for bringing it to my attention.