To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=157674
19 messages

BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?

10 Jul 15 - 01:17 PM (#3722659)
Subject: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Mrrzy

I think sexism, but with all the hoohaw on racism, I'm interested in other opinions.


10 Jul 15 - 01:19 PM (#3722661)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Rapparee

I find the lack of access for the disabled in the UK and Europe in general appalling. Talk about discrimination!


10 Jul 15 - 01:41 PM (#3722671)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: frogprince

I find it hard to give a really meaningful answer, Mrrzy. Which would you prefer to scrub out of the carpet, vomit or feces? Sexism is directed against half, or a scosh more than half, of the population. Racism (within a nation)is generally directed against minorities. Both degrade the lives of many more people than those they are directed against. Sexism is much less likely to be literally murderous.


10 Jul 15 - 03:13 PM (#3722692)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: GUEST,pete from seven stars link

good point, frogprince.   even when not murderous genuine racism is likely to have a hate element, whereas sexism exhibits a superior attitude to the opposite gender. goes both ways btw.


10 Jul 15 - 03:36 PM (#3722698)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: meself

'Sexism is much less likely to be literally murderous.'

Really? I would have thought the opposite.


10 Jul 15 - 04:04 PM (#3722709)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: GUEST,frogprince at the gallery

Personally, I've never heard any male say "The only good woman is a dead woman". I wish I had never heard the same statement with reference to a racial minority member.


10 Jul 15 - 04:29 PM (#3722715)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: meself

Maybe it's where we live. Where I live, it seems rare that the local media is not following a local case of a woman having been murdered by a man: woman missing, body found, suspect sought, man arrested, woman missing, body found .... etc. Cases of a member of a racial minority having been murdered by a white person do seem rare, though (no, I'm not going to look up the statistics).


10 Jul 15 - 04:49 PM (#3722719)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Greg F.

Both are worse.


10 Jul 15 - 05:26 PM (#3722731)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Greg F.

Oh, and speaking of racism: Click Here


10 Jul 15 - 06:32 PM (#3722744)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Bee-dubya-ell

Racism is more prevalent in some aspects of life, such as the criminal justice system. Blacks get stopped by cops for Driving While Black. Women don't usually get stopped for Driving While Female.

Sexism is more prevalent in the workplace. Outside of a handful of dyed-in-the-wool bigots, most employers wouldn't even consider paying a black man less than a white man for doing the same work. But many routinely pay women much less than men.


10 Jul 15 - 06:41 PM (#3722747)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: GUEST,pete from seven stars link

do you think those women were murdered because of gender prejudice, meself ?. I would have thought horribly gone wrong domestics mostly.


10 Jul 15 - 08:30 PM (#3722766)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Ebbie

My vote goes to racism. Sexism is something that can be fixed- or at least made impractical. Racism comes from a deep place and blankets an entire nation.


10 Jul 15 - 08:33 PM (#3722767)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: GUEST,mg

Racism.


10 Jul 15 - 10:04 PM (#3722779)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Richard Bridge

I think that somebody should get the death stats together. I suspect that sexism is more prevalent, but that on a death-per-bigot basis racism is more deadly. But as a result of the prevalence of sexism I would not be surprised if more women in total died (including as a result of so-called "honour killings") as a result of sexism than non-whites as a result of racism. Surely the cliche "If I can't have you nobody will" would not have become a cliche unless a commonplace.


10 Jul 15 - 11:10 PM (#3722784)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Stilly River Sage

I agree with Richard, though not for the "honor killings" reason. Simply because more women are kidnapped, raped, assaulted, and often murdered by boyfriends or estranged husbands and the news media barely bats an eye. Second class citizens. This is layered over a complex intersection, where low income and minority women are invisible. If murder involves a well-to-do woman, or a woman with a family who are listened to when they speak out, then you hear about it.


10 Jul 15 - 11:28 PM (#3722788)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: michaelr

'Sexism is much less likely to be literally murderous.'

Really? I would have thought the opposite.


Well, one clue is that you don't read a lot about the cops shooting large numbers of unarmed women.


10 Jul 15 - 11:32 PM (#3722790)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: Stilly River Sage

No. And you don't read about all of the women who are murdered by ex boyfriends and husbands. But it happens. All. Of. The. Time.


11 Jul 15 - 05:56 AM (#3722831)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: GUEST,Peter Laban

This article, which appeared in the Irish Times recently, may give a bit of a different perspective to the 'sure, sexism isn't so bad' line:

-I will not tell girls not to walk alone. I will not tell them to be careful-


11 Jul 15 - 06:27 AM (#3722839)
Subject: RE: BS: Which is worse in US, Sexism or Racism?
From: akenaton

I seem to remember the phrase "The only good injun....." from the old cowboy films of my youth, the media was indoctrinating us even then.

Of course the "Indians" were shown using barbaric cruelty, murder and rape of white women, the killing of children and the scalping of victims.....which at the time demonised the race.

I am sure these barbarities did happen, but we as children were quite unaware of the political and social implications of white colonisation.