Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (e.g., Mangione)

19 Dec 24 - 05:43 PM (#4213764)
Subject: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: Stilly River Sage

The story big in the news now (December 2024) is of the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson by Luigi Mangione. And a lot of legal scholars, news reporters, and pundits have remarked on the huge fanbase that has arisen following Mangione. Some are puzzled by the support of his act and offer of fake alibis and such by those followers. There are fan pages and posts all over social media.

I haven't looked into it closely, but in what I have heard and read, I haven't come across the terms "vigilante" or "antihero" to describe the response to Mangione, but that seems to actually be the case. He is like a modern day Joaquin Murrieta or Jesse James as far as a large swath of the public is concerned. Maybe a John Dillinger.

Despite his privileged background, Mangione was able to work up a lot anger and hatred for health insurance companies and the head of this largest one in particular. His murderous act spoke to millions of people who have been victimized by these companies. People who, like apparently most Americans, have a soft spot for the anti-hero.

This seems to be something that Mudcat can address musically. In several search attempts I found lots of murder ballads but the closest I come to a similar character is Jesse James (above) and his taking on the banks in his era or Bonnie and Clyde.

UnitedHealthcare CEO murder suspect Luigi Mangione faces federal charges after waiving extradition

Similar figures (modern, historical, and fictional) include Robin Hood, the Scarlet Pimpernel, Michael Corleone (The Godfather), D. B. Cooper, Thelma and Louise, Tony Soprano. The character Keller in Lawrence Block mysteries. Stories where murder seems an acceptable outcome.

Will there be any songs about Mangione?

---

19 Dec 24 - 06:15 PM (#4213765)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: gillymor

Vigilante Man- Ry Cooder Woody Guthrie Dust Bowl Ballad that doesn't exactly fit this sad story but a good song nonetheless.

---

19 Dec 24 - 06:21 PM (#4213766)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: gillymor

and Woody's Pretty Boy Floyd by The Byrds.

---

20 Dec 24 - 01:56 PM (#4213797)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST

ChatGPT Luigi Mangione song

https://youtu.be/jMFEe2bUKRo?si=7hVDEQykW6hHEZJk

This is getting way out of hand

---

21 Dec 24 - 05:20 AM (#4213821)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST

What's "heroic" about shooting an unarmed man in the back ?

---

21 Dec 24 - 05:44 AM (#4213822)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,Steve Shaw

Dunno about Ry Cooder and the Byrds. Give me Woody songs sung by Woody any day!

---

21 Dec 24 - 07:02 AM (#4213825)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: gillymor

Woody was a great songwriter but I've found most of his recordings to be unlistenable. Helluva thing to say on a folk music site and I agree with Guest, I don't think this incident was vigilantism, it was just plain murder.

---

21 Dec 24 - 11:53 AM (#4213828)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,GUEST Thompson

I'd see someone like climate activist Gaie Delap as more songworthy, but America is a country of guns…

---

21 Dec 24 - 12:44 PM (#4213829)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,paperback

I'm seeing some irony here thinking it over this morning.

A man allegedly shoots someone for allegedly using a computer program to allegedly deny his insurance claim then someone uses computer programs to compose a song about it.

Tolkien was right. The servants of the machine won WWII.

---

21 Dec 24 - 01:09 PM (#4213830)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: Stilly River Sage

What's "heroic" about shooting an unarmed man in the back ?

That's part of the puzzle.

He was unarmed, but he certainly was dangerous.

Revenge, getting the attention of the insurance business in general, making an example of someone who chose to run a business this way (would it operate that way regardless of who is in charge)?

---

21 Dec 24 - 03:58 PM (#4213836)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,Phil d'Conch

The first thing we do, let's kill all the lawyers...

Actuarial science
Actuary

In this context, proportionally speaking, Mr. vigilante Mangione would be a cold blooded, back shooting, murderous coward. Today it's 'health care.' And tomorrow…???

---

21 Dec 24 - 04:24 PM (#4213839)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST

And tomorrow?
The messenger

---

21 Dec 24 - 05:16 PM (#4213843)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,henryp

The Ballad of Ned Kelly (Trevor Lucas) by Fotheringay
Released on Fotheringay 1970

Viva Zapata (Andy Irvine) by Andy Irvine
Released on Rude Awakening 1991

Ballads of Sacco & Vanzetti written and performed by Woody Guthrie
Also Facing the Chair by Andy Irvine

Tom Joad by Woody Guthrie - Tom Joad and Preacher Casy

Lots of songs about Robin Hood

Lots of songs about outlaws, thieves, criminals and murderers, of course
e.g. Bonnie and Clyde

---

21 Dec 24 - 06:56 PM (#4213857)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,Thompson

The Night Before Larry was Stretched, though it's more of a general criminal song. The Boston Burglar. Now don't go moonlight wandering, for you'll break the laws of man. The Wild Colonial Boy

---

21 Dec 24 - 07:06 PM (#4213860)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,Thompson

And of course Éamonn a' Chnuic - and here's his story told by a local child in the Dúchas collection of béaloideas.

---

21 Dec 24 - 07:47 PM (#4213862)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,Steve Shaw

"Woody was a great songwriter but I've found most of his recordings to be unlistenable."

Well there's no accounting for taste. Maybe Woody is a prophet without honour in his own country...

---

21 Dec 24 - 08:32 PM (#4213865)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST

For some of you Paddy, Taffy, Jock and XXXX blokes

SLO outlaws

---

21 Dec 24 - 08:54 PM (#4213866)
Subject: RE: Songs about vigilante anti-heroes (Mangione)
From: GUEST,paperback

Probably not really the type of poetry for Advent

a slam poem by Joaquin Zihuatanejo This is a suit

---