To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=34029
27 messages

Help: Fanny Power

07 May 01 - 10:34 AM (#456920)
Subject: Fanny Power
From: Kim C

Is "Fanny Power" the same as "Planxty Fanny Powers"?


07 May 01 - 11:03 AM (#456930)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Bert

I'm sure the Brits are going to have fun with this thread.


07 May 01 - 11:20 AM (#456943)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Kim C

I'll bet. ;-) But this is a real question.


07 May 01 - 11:21 AM (#456946)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Pinetop Slim

A few threads here lead to a Carolan web site that might hold your answer.


07 May 01 - 11:43 AM (#456967)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: jeffp

Kim, I've seen the tune listed as Fanny Power, Planxty Fanny Power, and Mrs. Power. As far as I know, they're all the same tune. It's a lovely one, too.

jeffp


07 May 01 - 12:14 PM (#456989)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Homeless

I've also seen it as Planxty Fanny Poer and Fany Poer. The only difference I've seen/heard is in embellishments, depending on which instrument the music is for/played on.


07 May 01 - 12:19 PM (#456996)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: RichM

I thought "Fanny Power" was a political slogan...


07 May 01 - 01:40 PM (#457080)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Ian HP

Yes, it's the same. In later collections lots of Carolan's tunes had 'Planxty' added erroneously. A planxty seems to have been just a tune Carolan made for a patron. It's the same with Colonel John Irwin, which became, in later collections, Planxty Irwin, The Two William Davises, which became wrongly titled as Planxty Davis or Planxty Davy, etc etc. Few of the original titles were called Planxty. If you go to my website - http://ianhp.tripod.com - you'll find a link to a great Carolan website (sorry, remember my own URL offhand but not the Carolan one)


07 May 01 - 01:42 PM (#457084)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Snuffy

When Spaw's around it's a renewable energy source.


07 May 01 - 01:55 PM (#457097)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: wysiwyg

Well, it is said on the South Side of Chicago, "The bigger the cushion, the better the pushin'." This would provide a (hahah) firm theoretical foundation for the blues piece "Built for Comfort" as well, if sung by a lady with a strong-bottomed voice.

As a political slogan, however, it combines well with that other item that always casues me to raise a fist in a power salute as we go down life's path: "End Road Work". Yeah! End Road Work! Fanny Power!

Isn't there also an alternate title for Carolan's Concerto involving Mrs. Poer?

~S~


07 May 01 - 03:38 PM (#457236)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Ian HP

Kim, just had another thought: Planxty Fanny Power and Fanny Power are the same, but NOT to be confused with another tune called Mrs. Power (or Poer), otherwise known as Carolan's Concerto. Despite what jeffp says above, Fanny Power and Mrs. Power are not the same tune. For more info see the Carolan website I mention above.


07 May 01 - 03:44 PM (#457244)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: jeffp

I stand corrected. Susan, you had it right. According to that site, Carolan's Concerto is also known as Mrs. Power.

jeffp


07 May 01 - 03:48 PM (#457249)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: wysiwyg

So... is Mrs. Power named Fanny, or is Fanny a relative of Mrs.?

~S~


07 May 01 - 03:50 PM (#457252)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: wysiwyg

So... is Mrs. Power named Fanny, or is Fanny a relative of Mrs.?

~S~


07 May 01 - 05:42 PM (#457363)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: GUEST,Claymore

Actually, a group from Shepherdstown played last year at the annual concert at the Paw Paw, WV nudist colony. And with a slightly harder emphasis on the first word of the title, they got a standing ovation, whereupon the flautist lost her music, and the guitarist pinned his to the music stand from underneath.

The musicians were allowed to be clothed, and pictures which taken from behind the audience towards the stage, made the front page of the local paper. This year, they allegedly have musical groups paying to play... now that's Fanny Power


07 May 01 - 05:50 PM (#457369)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Kim C

Thanks y'all. I have a tune labeled Planxty Fanny Powers in one of my books and I just wondered. :-)


07 May 01 - 06:07 PM (#457377)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: catspaw49

You're right Snuffy......I got it!!!

Claymore, 30 years or so back I rode through Paw-Paw and never thought a thing about it. Another great failing of my youth.........'Course the only thing I saw then was sign that said I was in Paw-Paw and about 6 houses.

Spaw


07 May 01 - 07:41 PM (#457433)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Mike Byers

The information I have says that Fanny (Frances) Power was the daughter of David Power of Coorheen. She married Richard Trench of Garbally in 1732, and some copies of the tune were called "Mrs. Trench". In the words accompanying the tune (which I unfortunately don't have), I understand that Carolan says he hopes to live to dance at her wedding.


07 May 01 - 07:44 PM (#457434)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Dave the Gnome

I once saw a poster saying Fanny and supporting band...

But that was in the 60's. Does it count...;-)

DtG


07 May 01 - 08:04 PM (#457444)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Helen

One of the best Carolan sites I know of is
this one, run by Lesley, who Mudcats as well. Go to the Carolan section, but don't forget to have a look at Barry Taylor's tunes, also a Mudcatter, who does some of the most beautiful arrangements of folk tunes I have heard.

http://www.contemplator.com/

By the way, Fanny Power is one of my favourite Carolan tunes on the Celtic harp.

Helen


08 May 01 - 05:54 PM (#458240)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Kim C

Thanks y'all. ;-)


09 May 01 - 10:44 AM (#458663)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: GUEST,Mj

I have heard it referred to (jokingly obviously) as Womens Lib.

Mj


09 May 01 - 01:46 PM (#458807)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Liz the Squeak

The information I have says that Fanny (Frances) Power was the daughter of David Power of Coorheen. She married Richard Trench of Garbally in 1732, and some copies of the tune were called "Mrs. Trench". In the words accompanying the tune (which I unfortunately don't have), I understand that Carolan says he hopes to live to dance at her wedding.

That would make them Dick and Fanny Trench - even more smutty inuendo!!

Interesting that in the US, the fanny is the back bottom, and in the UK it's the front bottom...... wonder which one was first?

LTS


09 May 01 - 04:05 PM (#458936)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Kim C

I once dated a guy whose mother's given name was Fanny. She changed it to Lou. :-)


09 May 01 - 04:11 PM (#458939)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Mike Byers

I think we're gonna need some "Fanny Power!" bumper stickers...


09 May 01 - 04:30 PM (#458956)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: MMario

from this site:Naval Terminology, Jargon and Slang FAQ fanny - at least about the time canned meat was introduced, was canned meat.

and from this site:word and phrase origin of the day

"Fanny Adams was murdered and mutilated in 1812, her body cut into pieces and thrown into the River Wey at Alton in Hampshire. Her murderer, one Fred Baker, was publicly hanged in Winchester. Young Fanny Adams's name, give wide currency, was adopted by sailors to indicate a particularly distasteful meal, since Fanny Adams had been disposed of in a kettle. In fact, when kettles came into use in the British navy they were dubbed Fannys as were tins or cans of meat. There is no doubt that Fanny Adams is the basis for the military expression Sweet Fanny Adams, meaning something worthless or nothing at all. "


09 May 01 - 05:12 PM (#458996)
Subject: RE: Help: Fanny Power
From: Shamrock

We like to play Fanny Power and then go into the Marino Wattz. they go together nicely.

Sorry, if I have changed the subject.