To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=4913
57 messages

The World's Oldest Folk Song?

06 May 98 - 04:46 AM (#27440)
Subject: Oldest folk
From: steve t

Dulcimer asked when music started getting written down. Does anyone know the following trivia:

Oldest record of singing

Oldest lyrics that have always been sung

Oldest non-ceremonial / non-professional (ie folk) song

Oldest folk song for which we still know tune

The age of that prehistoric flute they found with a modern 7 note scale.


06 May 98 - 06:42 AM (#27448)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Frank in the swamps

Steve, you can find a good read on the neolithic flute at

http://www.sciam.com/0997issue/0997scicit4.html

If you can get a hard copy of the magazine, you might get a little more info. They often abreviate their online articles.

Frank.


06 May 98 - 10:48 AM (#27467)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Jon W.

Well, let's see--Homer wrote his epics when? about 700-800 B.C.? They were sung, were they not? David wrote his psalms around 1000 B.C. and included musical directions in some of them. 500 years before that, Moses sang a song after escaping from the Egyptians, the lyrics are in the book of Exodus. The Epic of Gilgamesh predates that by several hundred years, I believe. Was it sung? These should qualify for your first two questions. As for the oldest non-professional/non-ceremonial song, find the age of the oldest professional/ceremonial song, post date it by ten minutes, and you're there. Human nature being what it is, I'm sure there was some wag around making a parody of it as soon as it left the lips of the originator.

I'll leave the forth question for Bruce O. and Frank I.T.S has answered the fifth.


06 May 98 - 12:25 PM (#27482)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Earl

My guess for oldest song is the Na-nana-na-na-na song mentioned in the "American Cultural Oddites" thread.


06 May 98 - 12:51 PM (#27487)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bruce O.

I don't know if Gilgamesh was even poetical. The Descent of Inanna (in which her brother, Gilgamesh, appears) is poetical, but I don't know if it was sung. I seem to recall that the Opie's ODNR has a facsimile of the early "I have 4 sisters beyond the sea" (I gave my love a cherry without a stone).


06 May 98 - 03:33 PM (#27497)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bruce O.

Correction, it is the poetic tale 'The Huluppu Tree', not 'The Descent of Inanna' that Gilgamesh appears as Inanna's brother. In 'The Courtship of Inanna and Dumuzi' (the bawdy one) Dumuzi came to her singing, but it's not obvious the any of the poetic tales are songs.


06 May 98 - 05:40 PM (#27513)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bill D

There is a record somewhere for a Egyptian water-hauling chant/song from 4000 years ago..


06 May 98 - 07:49 PM (#27538)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Tim Jaques tjaques@netcom.ca

How did they get the tune for the 4000 year old chant? Were Egyptian water haulers still singing it, or did the ancient Egyptians leave some form of musical notation that we managed to decipher?

What is the oldest known folk song in English? Was, for instance, the song about King John and the Abbot of Canterbury actually written in the time of King John?

The Ballad of Robin Hood must be fairly old.


07 May 98 - 02:01 PM (#27625)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bruce O.

"Summer is Icumen In" may be the oldest in English with music. The version of "King John and the Abbot of Canterbury" that is known now was published between 1683 and 1685. There's an older version in the Percy Folio MS, but was it a ballad? Same goes for the early Robin Hood's that Child gave, no evidence as a ballad (many early pieces in Child and and others in Percy Folio MS appear more like 'metrical histories' (poetic tales) rather than ballads. I take ballad to mean now that it was in poetical form and was sung. This was not the case in earlier centuries for all the pieces then called ballads.


07 May 98 - 03:38 PM (#27632)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bill D

as I understood it, they found heiroglyphics with some of the same words that were still being sung recently along the Nile...the details of the language has evolved, but the song seemed to be the same... a bit 'folk-processed', but still recognizable. After all, the job it was written for has changed little in thousands of years. I suppose that if we still had lots of sailing ships, we'd still be singing sea chanties 'seriously'...


07 May 98 - 09:47 PM (#27681)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Alice

A web page related to this topic is "A Brief History of Singing" at http://www.lawrence.edu/~koopmajo/
It mentions folk songs, sacred music, and art songs from 'prehistoric vocalism' to more recent history.

alice


07 May 98 - 10:16 PM (#27683)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Alice

Here is a quote from the web page I noted in my last message.
......(the oldest)

----

It is a song, the Sumerian Hymn to Creation, dated before 800 B.C., which is the oldest notated music extant. Egyptian musical culture existed by the 4th millennium B.C., and music was prominent in the social and religious life of the Old Kingdom. Egyptian instruments changed significantly as the New Kingdom era (1700-1500 B.C.) began. The change, which may have reflected foreign influence, was from delicate timbre instruments to louder ones and was surely followed by similar changes in singing tone for, over time, a culture's instrumental timbres and vocal tone always tend to match. There are many drawings extant which confirm that large choruses and orchestras existed in the New Kingdom.

Grecian culture had a highly developed art music which showed signs of both a folk music origin and some Egyptian influence. The poetry of Sappho (600 B.C.) and others was often sung in contests, with melodies and rhythms based on the poetic meters. Singing was associated with all forms of literature and with dance. The ode, the dithyramb (a choral tribute to Bacchus and the forerunner of tragedy) and the drama all employed singers who moved to the rhythm of the music. By 500 B.C. ventriloquism had been described and both choruses and solo voices were being used in drama. Greek philosophers attached great value to music and to its cultural purposes. The PYTHAGOREAN SCALE (see Glossary) and a complex theory of music were developed.

The Judaic culture has preserved some melodies that may go back to 500 B.C. The Psalms of David and the Song of Solomon were sung, and we know of an early presence of professional musicians. Both responsorial (a soloist answered by the congregation) and antiphonal (alternating congregational groups) styles were used in singing the Psalms. After the destruction of the Second Temple, in 70 A.D., Jewish music became exclusively vocal. As the dispersed and transient Jews would learn, the human voice is a readily portable instrument, and communal singing serves to bond its participants in both form and purpose. Like the Egyptians, Jewish singers may have shared musical directions and reminders with hand-signs (CHEIRONOMY). Cantillation, the intoning of sacred texts using ancient melodic formulae, written with symbols called ta'amim, was an important musical format. Jewish prayer chants, which were based on ancient melodic lines and often highly ornamented, would have a considerable influence on Christian plainchant.

alice


08 May 98 - 05:05 AM (#27715)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Frank in the swamps

Alice, thanks for the url. Here's another one.

The Cantigas de de Santa Maria, 13 century Spanish collection of songs. Facsimiles, images and more...

http://www.pbm.com/~lindahl/cantigas/

Enjoy, Frank i.t.s.


09 May 98 - 12:46 PM (#27839)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bill D

found this while searching...

also this which includes this paragraph in a lengthy article

"The field of Greek folk - i.e. non-ecclesiastical - music has benefited in particular from the Athonite music manuscripts since, thanks to the monks' love of music, they contain the only surviving examples of songs, scored with Byzantine notation. Iviron Cod. 1189 from the year 1562 contains the oldest song set to music. The well-known thirteen songs in Cod. 1203 (ca. 1700), also from Iviron, and the three in Xeropotamou Cod. 262 (early 17th c.) provide a firm basis for the study of folk music. In addition, mention ought to be made of Vatopedi Cod. 1428, written in 1818 by Nikephoros Kantouniaris ('archimandrite of the throne of Antioch'), which is the fullest collection of songs of all types, principally urban ones. "


10 May 98 - 05:42 AM (#27878)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: steve t

Regarding Summer is Iccumen In, RUS claims it's the earliest part music in existance, dating back to the 13th century -- the oldest manuscript of part music anyway. Of course, RUS has been known to make an error now and then...


10 May 98 - 12:08 PM (#27888)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Alice

If we are not limiting ourselves to the English language...13th century ... not all that long ago. No one has mentioned China and the rest of Asia. Here is a website
http://www.melodyofchina.com/mr/
Chinese Music Research

One publication listed with a description in their newsletter page is "Chinese Folk Songs and Folk Singers".

Alice


10 May 98 - 05:48 PM (#27908)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Tim Jaques tjaques@netcom.ca

What about Beowulf? Is there any evidence that it was ever sung, perhaps by professional minstrels?


10 May 98 - 08:29 PM (#27919)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Alice

I went for a long scenic drive up the Gallatin River canyon today, and listened to one of my favorite Hawaiian recordings... Israel Kamakawiwo'ole, 'Facing Future'. I thought of this thread discussion. Anyone know the history of Polynesian music? Back in the 70's I learned a Maori war chant dance, some Tahitian, and both ancient and modern Hula. I have a video that is a documentary of the Merry Monarch Festival. The dance and music is incredible.

Alice


11 May 98 - 01:43 PM (#27975)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Bruce O.

Beowulf: It is clear that the poem as we now have it wasn't sung to a fixed tune as we would call it today. There are anywhere from 4 to 8 stressed syllables per line. In his notes to his translation, 1963, Burton Raffel suggested that the poem was an extended version of an old song. Robert P. Creed in the 'Afterword' suggested it was chanted and the harp mentioned was played only when the chanter or reciter was silent (catching his breath orn resting).


26 Feb 00 - 09:40 PM (#185516)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Metchosin

"In this dim prehistoric world, music had magic powers: people thought it could heal sickness, purify the body and mind and work miracles in the realm of nature. Similar powers are attributed to music in the Old Testament" from A History of Western Music

"same as it ever was".... Once In a Lifetime.... Talking Heads


26 Feb 00 - 09:54 PM (#185521)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Metchosin

Windplayer magazine reported that in 1995, archaeologists in Slovenia on a routine dig unexpectedly unearthed the oldest musical instrument ever found—a flute carved by a Neanderthal sometime between 43,000 and 80,000 years ago from the thighbone of a now-extinct cave bear. When the location of its tone holes was analyzed, it became apparent that the prehistoric flute was designed to play a diatonic scale, the same do-re-mi progression that we know from Western music.


26 Feb 00 - 09:58 PM (#185524)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Metchosin

guess that really makes some of us truly Neanderthals, eh


26 Feb 00 - 10:06 PM (#185530)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Metchosin

and you can read more about it if you click here


26 Feb 00 - 10:10 PM (#185532)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Metchosin

sorry Frank, as always I am a little redundant.


26 Feb 00 - 10:29 PM (#185538)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: kendall

As I understand it, THE FOX dates back to about 1100 ad


27 Feb 00 - 08:36 PM (#185926)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: McGrath of Harlow

Singing goes way back before humans.


28 Feb 00 - 06:05 AM (#186069)
Subject: RE: Oldest folk
From: Crowhugger

I'm just guessing, but maybe the oldest music that's still being sung is from the Torah. I know diddley about the Jewish tradition beyond the visible things like kosher food/dishes and yarmulkas (sp?), but one example would be the Pesach ceremony, which has been sung since there was a reason to celebrate it. Surely the cantors were singing something before that?

Can someone with more than a passing knowledge help me out here?


Threads combined. Messages below are from a new thread.
-Joe Offer-


11 Nov 06 - 07:26 PM (#1883487)
Subject: The Worlds Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,Nick

Just wondering about something... and I know there will not be any definite answer, in fact the question is calculated to make sure there is not.
How far back can anyone claim to trace "The Oldest Folk Song" ? what sources support such a claim? What is the song? Would there be a difference between oldest FOLK song and oldest SONG?

Ogggg Now Sing..... Mastodon oh mastodon your tusks shine brightly.
Mastodon Oh Mastodon ........

Whack Fall The Day
Nick


11 Nov 06 - 07:42 PM (#1883500)
Subject: RE: The Worlds Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

It was likely a blues song. Something like

Gonna meet my baby, down near the poolhall light
Gonna meet my baby, down near the poolhall light
If that T-rex don't get me
Ever'thing gonna work out right


11 Nov 06 - 07:46 PM (#1883502)
Subject: RE: The Worlds Oldest Folk Song?
From: Dave'sWife

Guest_Nick is about to be eaten alive by mudcat purists who hate such threads and/or who will list seventeen older threads on similar sujects.

Duck Nick, duck!
    ...or by an Anonymous Fellow Poster who will dare to combine the threads so people can easily see what has been discussed before.
    I hate those pedantic lecture threads that condemn people for not knowing what was posted before.
    -Joe Offer-


11 Nov 06 - 07:53 PM (#1883509)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

Gonna help ol' Nick to see the doctor right away
Gonna help o'l Nick to see the doctor right away
He shoulda ducked real fast, baby
That's all I got to say


11 Nov 06 - 07:57 PM (#1883514)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

Gonna tell ol' Shambles that Joe done copped a thread
Gonna tell ol' Shambles that Joe done copped a thread
Gonna tell ol' Shambles
Exactly what the ChiefoftheMudcateditingteam done said


11 Nov 06 - 08:01 PM (#1883518)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

It is I, it is I, who will dare to combine these threads
Yes baby, it is I, it is I, who will dare to combine these threads
You listen to me baby
That's what the man done said


11 Nov 06 - 08:18 PM (#1883529)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

I have a classic blues song on the go and does anyone say anything about it? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Bah, humbug.

Bah, humbug baby, humbug is what I thay
Bah, humbug baby, humbug is what I thay
If you don't like my blues song
Bah, humbug is what I thay


12 Nov 06 - 01:53 PM (#1883938)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Q (Frank Staplin)

Suggested Reading:

"A History of Western Music," 1960 (7th ed. 2005), Grout, Palisca, and Burkholder, 965pp., W. W. Norton.
The standard on Western music.
Essentially begins with the Greek heritage and the early Christian church. Includes summaries of ancient Greek musical systems. The earliest notated fragment on papyrus (3rd or 2nd c. B. C.) is from "Orestes," by Euripides, part of the chorus. Th stele, with the skolion by Seikilos, is later, c. 1st c. ("As long as you live, be light-hearted. Let nothing trouble you. Life is only too short, and time takes its toll").

The 7th ed. is about $75 new, $55 used; the 6th ed (2000) about $12. The 4th ed., 1988 (mine) is a throw-away. Used in many university introductory music courses.

Nothing on Indian, Chinese ancient music.
---------------------------

Thrasher, A. R., 2001, "Chinese Musical Instruments," is an introduction into the music as well. Inexpensive.

Dattilam et al., 1997, "A Compendium of Ancient Indian Music," is expensive. Not seen.


12 Nov 06 - 10:11 PM (#1884346)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,dax

Without question the oldest song:
   "I'll Give My Love An Apple" by Eve and The Serpents.


12 Nov 06 - 10:42 PM (#1884363)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Warsaw Ed

"Don't Stand Under The Apple Tree With Anyone Else But Me"


13 Nov 06 - 07:05 AM (#1884540)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,Darowyn

From: Bruce O.

"Beowulf: It is clear that the poem as we now have it wasn't sung to a fixed tune as we would call it today. There are anywhere from 4 to 8 stressed syllables per line."

Well I'd guess that if you can't sing a sing with odd length lines, that makes the Psalms impossible as well as most of Paul Simon's songs!
Of course you can sing Beowulf, as long as you can get close to pronouncing the Anglo Saxon as if it was a living language and not an invocation to the Dark Gods of Hyperboria.
I know you can sing Beowulf, because I have done it- an extract from Chapter 11, not all of it- that would make Wagner's Ring cycle a three minute single by comparison!
There are academics who talk about the tune for Beowulf, mentions have been found of "up" and "down" phrases, possibly meaning imperfect and perfect cadences.   
Listen to the version on my website,
http://www.darowyn.co.uk
then tell me it can't be sung!
Cheers
Dave


13 Nov 06 - 10:45 AM (#1884685)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: leeneia

I'm interested in early music. The oldest pieces of playable, popular music that I have encountered are

Sumer is a-cumen in
Salve Regina
13th century works from southern France, such as Douce Dame Jolie
the cantigas collected by Alphonso IX of Spain. 13th C.

I don't know about the authenticity of the other pieces, but somewhere on the net I've seen facsimiles of the cantigas. These manuscripts are so vague (no keys, no time signatures, no bar lines) that I wondeer how anybody can say how the music went. However, people publish cantigas, and the results are sure fun to play. So we play them.


13 Nov 06 - 11:08 AM (#1884708)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,Jack Campin

"Douce Dame Jolie" is by Guillaume de Machaut, who was 14th century and not from southern France.

Some mediaeval rhythmic notation is quite precise - barlines don't make much difference. Ancient Greek notation was even better.

"Worldes blis" and "Westron wynde" are both older than "Sumer is icumen in". I think "Edi beo thu, hevene quene" is the oldest known English song. But none of these has survived in a continuous tradition. Maybe some of the Italian "laude" have?

I would bet this one is pretty old:

X:1
T:Bafta Hindi
S:Baheega Sidky Rasheed, Egyptian Folk Songs
M:2/4
L:1/8
K:D Minor
dd A    A|dd A    A|AA B    d|^cB A2 |
AA (B/A/)G|GG (A/G/)F|FF (G/F/)E| ED A2 |
AA (B/A/)G|GG (A/G/)F|FF (G/F/)E| ED D2|]

since as well as Egypt, it is known in Turkey (dunno the words) and in Italy it's a "tarantella".


13 Nov 06 - 11:19 AM (#1884716)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Paul Burke

One of the oldest songs must be the one that was sung by the ancient Phoenician sailors as they rested their oars after a hard day's rowing in the burning Mediterranean sun, and enjoyed the cool evening as the sun sank beyond the Pillars of Hercules:

Trireme goodnight,
Trireme goodnight,
Goodnight trireme,
Goodnight trireme,
I'll see you in my dreams.


13 Nov 06 - 11:36 AM (#1884732)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST

Stuck inside of Giza with the Memphis blues again.


13 Nov 06 - 04:06 PM (#1884937)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Cool Beans

"Hurray for Cave Seven!" (or something similar), from Mel Brooks and Carl Reiner's 2,000-year-old-man routine.


13 Nov 06 - 04:16 PM (#1884943)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST

Was it something by Tyrannosaurus Rex?


13 Nov 06 - 04:55 PM (#1884986)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: danensis

Diatomic kittens?


13 Nov 06 - 05:55 PM (#1885043)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

"One of the oldest songs must be the one that was sung by the ancient Phoenician sailors as they rested their oars after a hard day's rowing in the burning Mediterranean sun, and enjoyed the cool evening as the sun sank beyond the Pillars of Hercules:

Trireme goodnight,
Trireme goodnight,
Goodnight trireme,
Goodnight trireme,
I'll see you in my dreams."

That was so good I had to see it again!


13 Nov 06 - 05:56 PM (#1885044)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Peace

"Stuck inside of Giza with the Memphis blues again."

And that, too.


13 Nov 06 - 07:13 PM (#1885104)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Cool Beans

Going back to Q's citation from Euripides...So, that's like the early version of "Always Look on the Bright Side of Life." Hunh.
AS for "Beowulf" I hate the part where he eats the duck. Oh wait, that's "Peter and the Wolf." Never mind.


18 Jan 11 - 03:49 AM (#3076939)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,Ukkonen

"Frog went a courtin"

Mentioned in the literature earlier but MELODY WRITTEN DOWN 1611 in Scotland


18 Jan 11 - 06:16 AM (#3076988)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: MGM·Lion

In Europe, what of the Trouvère tradition of France & Navarre, cC12-C14?

Psalm 137, "By the waters of Babylon ... Sing us of the songs of Zion ... How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?" {the Lord's song presumably meaning one of their own, not the gentile Babylonians', so presumably not specifically religious}, seems to point to a well-established tradition of singing of songs [*shirim*] among the Jews at time of the Babylonian exiles, early C6 BCE [about 600-540].

... as e.g. the songs at the end of the Haggadah Passover service-book, traditional songs not of a specifically religious kind, like the children's cumulative song about the one kid that Father bought in the market for 2 farthings {anyone remember the film?}, which are intended presumably to provide some relaxation on what is supposed to be a celebratory occasion in which the children play a prominent part.

~Michael~


18 Jan 11 - 06:37 AM (#3077000)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Jack Campin

Source? The usual cite for that is Ravenscroft, who was from London.

The story ultimately goes back to Aesop, and an elaborated version of it that might have been known in Ravenscroft's time was the Scots one by Henryson (around 1490), but that's very far from being a folk song (probably never meant to be sung at all).


18 Jan 11 - 10:15 AM (#3077123)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,Neil D

Now I've heard there was a secret chord
That David played, and it pleased the Lord
But you don't really care for music, do you?
It goes like this
The fourth, the fifth
The minor fall, the major lift
The baffled king composing Hallelujah


18 Jan 11 - 02:25 PM (#3077321)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,andymac

No-one has mentioned the Norse sagas as examples of early European verse that would have been recited/sung on occasion. Not as old as some of the Middle Eastern examples mentioned but nonetheless pretty venerable.


18 Jan 11 - 04:32 PM (#3077422)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST

I always thought the oldest song was "If you are the only girl in the world" sung by a chap called Adam under an apple tree somewhere


18 Jan 11 - 06:43 PM (#3077522)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: Steve Gardham

A Lullaby?


19 Jan 11 - 04:34 AM (#3077725)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,Ukkonen

Music is surely as old as we are. No..wait.. much older.
I thought this topic was about the melody written down.


19 Jan 11 - 04:52 AM (#3077733)
Subject: RE: The World's Oldest Folk Song?
From: GUEST,sorry

Just read the 1st post again. I dont know where i got the idea from. Anyways.. froggie went a courtin´