If you really believe all the stuff you just said, Alice, t could be said that you are attributing all of those things to astrology because you are unable to see the real, underlying causes, and astrology is a a convenient bogeyman that you have conjured up because you need to find an "explanation"--this would make you the irrational "believer" --

I presume, because you are from a "Logical" family, that you are making these assertions for the purpose of argumentation and don't really believe that you are able to "see" why people do things--

You believe that astrology is wrong --so you misinterpret what people are saying here completely--many of the people who seem to you to have a "determined faith" (like me) have no particular stake in astrology at all, and are simply advocating toleration for different systems of thought-