Lizzie.
I've always considered The Cat, R2 F&A, fRoots, and Charlies boards, to be about like minded people exchanging information, and sharing knowledge.
Yes, I'm only human too, and sometimes get sucked into some Troll Fest. (Bulmer/Celtic, for instance.....Nooooo! don't start that one again.)
If I find a genuine question that I have the answer to, then I will reply.
I credit most people on these boards with a fair amount of intelligence. They have heard about Mr Lakeman, and SOH, and don't need it continually rammed down their throats.
On the Cat, it's very useful to me, that I can discuss Concertinas with people around the world (Hello to Bob Bolton in Oz !)
Have just helped someone on the Beeb board doing research into the songs and tunes of the East Riding of Yorkshire, who the best person is to contact.

That is the beauty and purpose of these boards IMHO.

It's always interesting to get a take on what is going on the other side of the pond, and indeed have made several friends because of it.
So Lizzie, great respect. but, sniping about other message boards on Mudcat only makes you look a bit bitter.

Thank God Max has not introduced Smilies.

Ralph

PS. Saw Charlie G a week or so ago, and he's in good spirits, but sad to have had to give up his R London show. He's still doing his World Service prog though. It's not so much of a strain.

Later!