I had problems listening to it all as I am only on Dialup.
I agree with the general impression (from what I heard) that it's not too bad a recording. Especially when you look at the cost, not even an hour of cheap studio time.
I too thought that the guitar and fiddle were a little too high and forward in the mix. The guitar also being a little too bright/trebley.
I quit liked the vocals sound.
The biggest thing which hit me, which nobody else seems to have mentioned, was a lack of synch between the two voices when the second voice came in. they were not together in time on the phrasing.
Absolutely nothing to do with the recording quality, however it would be a deterrent for me to buy a recording as it to me it is a performance glitch.
Keep up the good work and get the band to practise a bit more, re-record and re-post.