"but when your rationale is an historic border set up by the Romans and set aside 500 ish years ago,"

Well of course the border wasn't set up by the Romans and neither was it set aside 500 years ago. The Scottish and English kingdoms were formed into a single kingdom just over 300 years ago. That is by the by though as the vast majority of the Scottish people still regard themselves as a national people and regard Scotland as a distinct country within the union. The border as such still exists. Some wish to remain in the union - others wish to end it. It is a democratic choice. As for me being logged out of most people's thinking that is just silly. The vast majority of Scots were in favour of the referendum. None of the major British political parties seek to deny the Scots the democratic choice as to what they want. It is you who is totally out of kilter.