I think everyone agrees that there are two opposing views on the famine,nobody has given a head count on the supporters of either view.
You say "I do not have the knowledge to choose between them.
I just acknowledge that many and probably most historians do not agree with Jim on culpability"
Jim acknowledges the revisionists differ from him.
Neither of you can claim more historians agree with one or other view,
the best you can come up with is "many and probably most".