There is such a depth of knowledge among Mudcat contributors that someone must be - may be - bursting to write about a song they've always loved and has been covered, badly as they see it or well. The series is not just about my tastes - others have already chipped in - and I'd welcome additions.

I deliberately make it and/or rather than versus, though everyone has a preference and a robust opinion either way is absolutely acceptable.

Browse the series here - it's getting half-decent hits and you'll find Dylan, Kate Rusby, June Tabor, Pete Seeger, Byrds, Oysterband, Dubliners, Baez, Pogues, Christy Moore, Nolwenn Leroy and a procession of many others - and tell me by DM or at salutsunderland@gmail.com if you'd like to have a go.