"Baring-Gould's contact with folk singers goes back to the 1860s!" Baring Gould's work has only just become available for public consideration - his published song collections prior to the current book contain only notes to the songs As excellent as they are, they do not touch on the songs in context to the communities they come from As I said, our knowledge of that context stretches back to the beginning of the twentieth century, which is why Wilgus entitled his book as he did Even Steve Gardham has agreed that this is how far back our knowledge goes and we can only speculate on who made the songs It remains to be seen how much the Baring Gould Ms or the Sharp diaries - and all the other passing references add to the question "I have received two PMs advising me not to try to reason with Jim," And I have a log, arrogant and abusive PM from one of the protagonists here - wasn't it you who once told me that it was unethical to use PS in these arguments? PMs are for those who don't have the bottle to state their beliefs openly (talking behind ones back, in other words) Not something I puut a lot of trust in Shame on you Vic, using something you have yourself condemned - tsk-tsk! Perhaps you should follow your own advice Jim Carroll
|