Lyrics & Knowledge Personal Pages Record Shop Auction Links Radio & Media Kids Membership Help
The Mudcat Cafesj



User Name Thread Name Subject Posted
Robert B. Waltz Songs feat. standing stones, barrows etc (34) RE: Folklore: Songs feat. standing stones, barrows etc 23 Sep 23


FWIW, the already-cited ballad of The Standing Stones (Roud #2151) is the only traditional song I have encountered which seems to have a Magical Place of Stones motif.

henryp mentioned "Stanton Drew, where dancers on the Sabbath were turned to stone." That song does not appear to be traditional. The story of cursed dancers assuredly is -- relevant motifs in the Thompson index include (and may not be limited to):
D1415ff Magic object compels person to dance
D2061.1.2 Dancing self to death (to pay devil for clothes)
F4331.4 Persons magically caused to dance selves to death
Q388.1 Freemasons forced to dance until they sweat blood
Q414.4 Dances to death in red-hot shoes (That occurs in the German Cinderella versions!)

I don't know of a song about people dancing themselves to stone, but it has been suggested that there was a song version of The Cursed Dancers of Colbeck (I'll put the Ballad Index entry on that one at the end).

There is also the tale of "The Friar and the Boy," which has not been collected as a song but is included in the Percy Folio Manuscript ("Ffryar and Boye"), as well as the manuscripts of Richard Calle (source for "Robin Hood and the Potter"; late fifteenth century) and Richard Hill (source for the earliest version of the Corpus Christi Carol; early sixteenth century) among others. There is no question but that The Friar ans the Boy is traditional; the only question is whether it's a song. I summarize the summary by George Steevens: Steevens summarizes "The Friar and the Boy". The boy "suffers from the capricious cruelty of a mother-in-law." A magician gives the boy three gifts: "the first is an unerring bow; the second a pipe which would compel all who heard it to dance; the third must explain itself [makes his mother-in-law fart]." For revenge, mother-in-law employs "the frere ... to persecute the boye" who makes the friar dance until his clothes are shredded. The friar calls in a magistrate for relief. The magistrate, against the friar's warning, asks to hear the boy play; so, the boy "throws all the participants into another fit of dancing, in which the offycyall himself is compelled to join, and the stepdame [sic] exhibits fresh proofs of her flatulency. The tired magistrate at last entreats our hero to suspend his operations, and, on his compliance, immediately reconciles him to his enemies."

This is thought by some to be related to "Tom, Tom, the Piper's Son (II)," Roud #19621.

This of course has no direct connection to any particular location. But it's where magic forced dancing takes us....

APPENDIX

The Cursed Dancers of Colbeck


DESCRIPTION: On a Christmas morning, a group of young people gather to carol and dance. A priest, who is saying mass, looks on in disapproval. The young people cannot stop dancing; they dance for a year, until many die or go mad or wander broken in body
AUTHOR: unknown
EARLIEST DATE: (cannot be shown to have existed, but the underlying story was known by 1328)
KEYWORDS: dancing curse travel disease clergy religious MiddleEnglish
FOUND IN:
REFERENCES (3 citations):
RELATED: Versions of the "Cursed Dancers" section of Handlyng Synne --
Kenneth Sisam, editor, Fourteenth Century Verse and Prose, Oxford, 1925, pp. 4-12, "The Dancers of Colbeck" (1 text, of 256 lines)
Robert D. Stevick, Five Middle English Narratives, Bobbs Merrill, 1967, pp. 27-36, "The Cursed Dancers of Colbeck" (1 text, a heavily standardized version of Sisam's text)

CROSS-REFERENCES:
cf. "Judas" [Child 23] (subject: The Earliest English Ballad) and references there
NOTES [698 words]: This, like "The Knight of Liddesdale" [Child 160], is a "ballad on speculation" -- and the speculation in this case is even weaker than that for the "Knight."
The tale of the Cursed Dancers, although probably not actually true, is certainly ancient. Gerould, p. 207, reports that the tale, set in Kölbigk, was in circulation by the eleventh century, shortly after the alleged date of the tragedy.
The story of the Cursed Dancers is Thompson #C94.1.1 (although that number specifies that they must dance until the Judgment Day). Most of Thompson's citations appear to be German (or, in one case, Swiss), but he has one English and one Finnish/Swedish.
Brown, p. xi, mentions a tale told by Gerald of Wales (late twelfth century) that sounds a bit like this: A party of young people spent the night singing a song with the refrain "Swete lamman dhin are" (meaning, I think, [My] sweet leman/lover you are"). The priest, having been kept awake by the song, the next morning opened a service by singing that refrain rather than "Dominus vobiscum," resulting in a scandal.
Another version of the tale, closer to the original, says that a cursed dancer named Theodoric showed up at Wilton Abbey and was cured at the shrine of St. Editha (Gerould, p. 208). This would have allowed the story to reach England. Gerould quotes a bit of Latin verse about the story.
A ballad? Not even Gerould claims that. But Friedman, p. 16, following others who link the story to the evolution of carols, hints that he (or Gerould, or someone, at least) considers the tale of the Cursed Dancers to be a ballad.
Similarly, Chambers, p. 178, interprets Gerould as finding "the earliest European record of a ballad in the combination of dance and song and story described in the eleventh- or twelfth-century legend of the Dancers of Kölbigk."
If they are right and this is a ballad, it follows that, since the story is eleventh century, it is a candidate for the Earliest English Ballad. So here it is in the Index, even though this is probably the worst of all the "earliest ballad" candidates I've examined. And most of the cases are quite feeble.
Although the tale apparently goes back to the eleventh century, in England, it cannot be documented before the early fourteenth. In 1303, Robert Mannying of Brunne, or Bourne (sometimes called simply "Robert of Brunne") began to write Handlyng Synne ("Handling Sin") ("Þe ?eres of grace fyl þan to be / A þousynd and þre hundred and þre"; Sisam, p. 2). It was based on an apparently Anglo-Norman work (i.e. French, but written in England), William of Wad(d)ington's Manuel de (la) Pechiez or Manuel des Pechiez Mannyng's version is metrical and is more adaption than translation; William provided the framework, but Mannyng made the book his own. It is a collection of rules and commandments, often illustrated with exemplum, or tales illustrating the point. William deals with "the Commandments, the Sins, the Sacraments, the Requisites, and the Graces of Shrift. But such a bald summary gives no idea of the richness and variety of the content" (Sisam, pp. 2-3).
Most of Mannyng's content derives from William, but the story of the Cursed Dancers is an exception. This was taken from a Latin version; there is a related copy of this Latin source in MS. Rawlinson C 938 (Sisam, p. 3).
The story of the Cursed Dancers is lines 8987-9252 in Furnivall's standard edition of Mannyng, apparently based on MS. Harley 1701 of about 1375 (Sisam, p. 4); there is a second complete manuscript copy (Bodley 415) and another fragment; none of these is the original (Stevick, p. xix). This seems to be regarded as the most interesting part of Handlyng Synne; at least, it's the part reprinted by both Sisam and Stevick.
Emerson, p. 276, says that Mannying was born around 1260 and died around 1340. Emerson dates the Harley copy slightly earlier than Sisam, to c. 1360; since paleography generally cannot date a manuscript closer than the nearest fifty years, and sometimes not to the nearest hundred, this is a trivial difference. Either date would make the copy more than half a century more recent than Mannyng's translation, and a generation or so after his death.- RBW

Bibliography


  • Brown: Carleton Brown, editor, English Lyrics of the XIIIth Century, Oxford University Press, 1932 (I use the 1962 reprint)
  • Chambers: E. K. Chambers, English Literature at the Close of the Middle Ages, Oxford, 1945, 1947
  • Emerson: O. F. Emerson, A Middle English Reader, 1905; revised 1915 (I use the 1921 Macmillan hardcover)
  • Friedman: Albert B. Friedman, The Ballad Revival, University of Chicago Press, 1961
  • Gerould: Gordon Hall Geround, The Ballad of Tradition, Oxford University Press, 1932
  • Sisam: Kenneth Sisam, editor, Fourteenth Century Verse and Prose, Oxford, 1925
  • Stevick: Robert D. Stevick, Five Middle English Narratives, Bobbs Merrill, 1967

Last updated in version 5.3

File: NothCDCo


Post to this Thread -

Back to the Main Forum Page

By clicking on the User Name, you will requery the forum for that user. You will see everything that he or she has posted with that Mudcat name.

By clicking on the Thread Name, you will be sent to the Forum on that thread as if you selected it from the main Mudcat Forum page.

By clicking on the Subject, you will also go to the thread as if you selected it from the original Forum page, but also go directly to that particular message.

By clicking on the Date (Posted), you will dig out every message posted that day.

Try it all, you will see.