Wavestar,

What I don't understand is the contention that MAV and others seem to be making that each party should be the most extreme versions of themselves they can be.

Let me clarify then, the battle is not between Rs and Ds, but between conservatisim and liberalism. What results when compromise occurs is wish-washy moderatism. (Not a real policital position but a result of both)

Anyone who calls themself a moderate is just afraid to take a position or display any guiding principles. These politicians are the real liars (regardless of party) and will vote by public opinion poll to make sure they always get re-elected in order to perpetuate their cushy political careers.

Extremismof any sort is almost never the most practical or rational application of ideas or idealogies

Following the Constitution is not extremism.

Let me borrow a phrase and ask you to name all the great moderates who made their mark in history.

mav out